Making development assistance work for Africa: from aid-dependent disease control to the new public health order

Justice Nonvignon,Agnès Soucat,Paulina Ofori-Adu,Olusoji Adeyi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/czad092
2024-01-01
Health Policy and Planning
Abstract:Abstract The Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic has revealed the fragility of pre-crisis African health systems, in which too little was invested over the past decades. Yet, development assistance for health (DAH) more than doubled between 2000 and 2020, raising questions about the role and effectiveness of DAH in triggering and sustaining health systems investments. This paper analyses the inter-regional variations and trends of DAH in Africa in relation to some key indicators of health system financing and service delivery performance, examining (1) the trends of DAH in the five regional economic communities of Africa since 2000; (2) the relationship between DAH spending and health system performance indicators and (3) the quantitative and qualitative dimensions of aid substitution for domestic financing, policy-making and accountability. Africa is diverse and the health financing picture has evolved differently in its subregions. DAH represents 10% of total spending in Africa in 2020, but DAH benefitted Southern Africa significantly more than other regions over the past two decades. Results in terms of progress towards universal health coverage (UHC) are slightly associated with DAH. Overall, DAH may also have substituted for public domestic funding and undermined the formation of sustainable UHC financing models. As the COVID-19 crisis hit, DAH did not increase at the country level. We conclude that the current architecture of official development assistance (ODA) is no longer fit for purpose. It requires urgent transformation to place countries at the centre of its use. Domestic financing of public health institutions should be at the core of African social contracts. We call for a deliberate reassessment of ODA modalities, repurposing DAH on what it could sustainably finance. Finally, we call for a new transparent framework to monitor DAH that captures its contribution to building institutions and systems.
health care sciences & services,health policy & services
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore the fund allocation and trends of Development Assistance for Health (DAH) in African countries from 2000 to 2020, as well as its impact on the performance of the health system. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **The evolution of DAH in Africa's five regional economic communities**: Analyze the changes of DAH in different regions of Africa since 2000. 2. **The relationship between DAH expenditure and health system performance indicators**: Research whether and how the input of DAH has affected the performance of the health system, especially service provision and coverage. 3. **The quantitative and qualitative dimensions of aid substituting domestic financing, policy - making and accountability**: Evaluate whether DAH has partly replaced the domestic government's health expenditure and affected the policy - making and accountability mechanisms. 4. **The changes of DAH during the COVID - 19 crisis**: Explore the impact of the global pandemic on the pattern and scale of DAH, especially the specific changes at the national level. ### Main problems - **The effectiveness and sustainability of DAH**: The paper questions whether DAH has effectively triggered and maintained investment in the health system, especially in promoting Universal Health Coverage (UHC). - **Regional differences**: Emphasize the different evolution paths of health financing situations among African regions, and point out that DAH has benefited the most in southern Africa, while its role in other regions is limited. - **The impact of DAH on public financing**: Point out that DAH may replace domestic public funds to a certain extent, weakening the formation of a sustainable UHC financing model. - **The limitations of the current Official Development Assistance (ODA) architecture**: Believe that the existing ODA architecture no longer meets the needs and requires urgent reform so that recipient countries can make better use of these resources. ### Conclusion The paper calls for a re - evaluation of the ODA approach and a re - positioning of the use of DAH so that it can continuously support development in specific areas. At the same time, it is recommended to establish a new transparent framework to monitor DAH to ensure that it helps build the capacity of institutions and systems. In addition, it is emphasized that the financing of domestic public health institutions should be the core content of the African social contract. Through the above analysis, the paper reveals the complex role of DAH in the African health system and provides an important reference for future research and policy - making.