Abstract:A fundamental component in the theoretical school choice literature is the problem a student faces in deciding which schools to apply to. Recent models have considered a set of schools of different selectiveness and a student who is unsure of their strength and can apply to at most $k$ schools. Such models assume that the student cares solely about maximizing the quality of the school that they attend, but experience suggests that students' decisions are also influenced by a set of behavioral biases based on reputational effects: a subjective reputational benefit when admitted to a selective school, whether or not they attend; and a subjective loss based on disappointment when rejected. Guided by these observations, and inspired by recent behavioral economics work on loss aversion relative to expectations, we propose a behavioral model by which a student chooses schools to balance these behavioral effects with the quality of the school they attend. Our main results show that a student's choices change in dramatic ways when these reputation-based behavioral biases are taken into account. In particular, where a rational applicant spreads their applications evenly, a biased student applies very sparsely to highly selective schools, such that above a certain threshold they apply to only an absolute constant number of schools even as their budget of applications grows to infinity. Consequently, a biased student underperforms a rational student even when the rational student is restricted to a sufficiently large upper bound on applications and the biased student can apply to arbitrarily many. Our analysis shows that the reputation-based model is rich enough to cover a range of different ways that biased students cope with fear of rejection, including not just targeting less selective schools, but also occasionally applying to schools that are too selective, compared to rational students.

The effect of distance to colleges on application behaviour

Does Attending A Key School Have A Quality Premium? A Regression Discontinuity Analysis

The Disparate Impacts of College Admissions Policies on Asian American Applicants

Older and Wiser? Relative Age and Success in High School and College

Staying Close or Going Away: How Distance to College Impacts the Educational Attainment and Academic Performance of First-generation College Students

Why Does College Education Matter? Unveiling the Contributions of Selection Factors.

How have college decisions changed over time? An application of the conditional logistic choice model

The More Selective, the More Effective? the Geographical Difference of the Effectiveness of Selective Education

It’s Not Only Who You Are but Who You Are With: High School Composition and Individuals’ Attainment Over the Life Course

Do Academically Selective School Systems Strengthen the Link Between Students’ Family Backgrounds and the Likelihood of Higher Education Participation?

Does geodemographic segmentation influence higher education opportunity? A spatial investigation of enrollment at one Taiwanese university

The Institution of Merit: A Study of Chinese College Admissions

The Large Core of College Admission Markets: Theory and Evidence

How Do Academic Selection Systems Affect Pupils' Educational Attainment? New Evidence from an Analysis of Large-Scale Data on England

Can Greater Reliance on Test Scores Ameliorate the Association Between Family Background and Access to Post-Collegiate Education? Survey Evidence from the Beijing College Students Panel Survey.

Modeling reputation-based behavioral biases in school choice

Catching Up-Academic Performance of Students from Different Regions

The Cost of Attending an Elite College

Conditions of Access to the University:Constraints of College Access and the Analysis

Isolating Peer Effects in the Returns to College Selectivity