Abstract:Does the enemy of my enemy become my friend? A growing literature on structural analysis of interstate relationships has tackled this old question from the network perspective. However, the mechanism of long-term change in the structure of cooperation and enmity has yet to be fully understood. In search for a general explanation for the long-term evolution of interstate structure, we empirically examine the structural balance theory which predicts that a signed network evolves toward a more "balanced" structure where in many triangular relationships (i.e., triads) two states tend to share a common enemy or three states cooperate with each other. We investigate the network of alliances (positive edges) and rivalries (negative edges) between sovereign states and examine whether its evolution from 1816 to 2009 can be explained by the structural balance theory. We find the consistency with the structural balance theory drastically changes over time. The empirical pattern follows the prediction by the theory before the German unification in the nineteenth century and after World War II while inconsistent in the middle period. This result reveals the impact of the two historical events on the underlying mechanism of network evolution. Moreover, the contrast with previous studies of signed social networks that generally support the structural balance theory indicates that international alliance and rivalry networks can be a promising material to study novel mechanisms behind the time evolution of signed networks.

Kantian fractionalization predicts the conflict propensity of the international system

Escalation of a local conflict into a Cold War

Multiplex communities and the emergence of international conflict

Empirical Support for Systemic and Dyadic Explanations of International Conflict

Triangulating War: Network Structure and the Democratic Peace

Dynamic Stochastic Blockmodel Regression for Network Data: Application to International Militarized Conflicts

Alliances and Conflict, or Conflict and Alliances? Appraising the Causal Effect of Alliances on Conflict

Structural balance of alliance and rivalry networks in international relations

Optimizing conflicts in the formation of strategic alliances

Networks in Conflict: Theory and Evidence from the Great War of Africa

Structured Inequality, Conflict, and Control: A Cross-National Test of the Threat Hypothesis

When Do Conflicting Political Relations Affect International Trade?

Conflicts in Spatial Networks

Conflict Fragmentation Index

International Relations Theory and the Relationship across the Taiwan Strait

International Systems and Domestic Politics: Linking Complex Interactions with Empirical Models in International Relations

Goodbye to all that? Institutionalist theory, U.S. alliances, and Donald Trump

A hostile reputation: A social network approach to interstate hostility

Political Irrelevance, Democracy, and the Limits of Militarized Conflict

Modeling and Controlling Interstate Conflict

Liberalism and Interdependence: Extending the Trade-Conflict Model