Leading US particle-physics lab faces uncertain future

Dan Garisto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-00150-4

IF: 64.8

2024-01-26

Nature

Abstract:Several organizations are vying for the contract to manage Fermilab, after it received failing grades from the US Department of Energy. Several organizations are vying for the contract to manage Fermilab, after it received failing grades from the US Department of Energy.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Fermilab gets a not-quite-new boss to tackle its troubles

Adrian Cho

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adt7203

IF: 56.9

2024-10-11

Science

Abstract:University of Chicago will again lead a group to manage the United States's only dedicated particle physics lab

multidisciplinary sciences
Preparing Fermilab to Carry Out the P5 Plan

Giorgio Bellettini

2024-07-31

Abstract:In the past several years, Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (Fermilab) has suffered a number of troublesome setbacks. In some cases, failures to respond effectively have only made things worse, resulting in the current crisis atmosphere at the laboratory. This is reflected in part in the poorly rated performance appraisals (or PEMP) that the DOE provides to the lab every year. Three entities are currently responsible for supporting, managing, operating, and leading the lab: the Department of Energy (DOE), Fermi Research Alliance (FRA), and the Laboratory Director Office. Two recent events provide opportunities for interested parties to reverse the recent decline: the release in December 2023 of the P5 Report and the DOE decision to rebid the Management & Operating (M&O) contract. The P5 Report a decadal update of recommendations for US particle physics, includes an ambitious and positive roadmap for projects and activities at Fermilab. Carrying out the P5 plan successfully, however, will also require addressing many of the other problems currently besetting the lab. The selection of a new M&O contractor is under the responsibility of the Deputy Director for Operations of the DOE Office of Science Dr. Juston Fontaine. A new M&O Contractor would replace FRA and name a new Director effective January 1, 2025. A new management team, one hopes, would be motivated to solve problems and would enjoy a honeymoon period, enabling them to make positive changes more easily. Stimulated by these recent developments, the authors of this document, all present or past employees, convened confidentially in order to collect testimonials on a series of events symptomatic of the lab problems, to provide constructive criticism and offer possible solutions. This document summarizes this work.

Accelerator Physics,Physics and Society
Fermilab Program and Plans

Dmitri Denisov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-0221/9/07/C07021

2014-08-05

Abstract:This article is a short summary of the talk presented at 2014 Instrumentation Conference in Novosibirsk about Fermilab's experimental program and future plans. It includes brief description of the P5 long term planning progressing in US as well as discussion of the future accelerators considered at Fermilab.

Instrumentation and Detectors,High Energy Physics - Experiment,Accelerator Physics
Vision to reality: From Robert R. Wilson's frontier to Leon M. Lederman's Fermilab

Lillian H. Hoddeson,Adrienne W. Kolb

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s000160300003

2011-10-04

Abstract:This paper examines the roles of vision and leadership in creating and directing Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory from the late 1960s through the 1980s. The story divides into two administrations having different problems and accomplishments, that of Robert R. Wilson (1967-1978), which saw the transformation from cornfield to frontier physics facility, and that of Leon Max Lederman (1979-1989), in which the laboratory evolved into one of the world's major high-energy facilities. Lederman's pragmatic vision of a user-based experimental community helped him to convert the pioneering facility that Wilson had built frugally into a laboratory with a stable scientific, cultural, and funding environment.

History and Philosophy of Physics
Future Collider Options for the US

P. C. Bhat,S. Jindariani,G. Ambrosio,G. Apollinari,S. Belomestnykh,A. Bross,J. Butler,A. Canepa,D. Elvira,P. Fox,Z. Gecse,E. Gianfelice-Wendt,P. Merkel,S. Nagaitsev,D. Neuffer,H. Piekarz,S. Posen,T. Sen,V. Shiltsev,N. Solyak,D. Stratakis,M. Syphers,G. Velev,V. Yakovlev,K. Yonehara,A. Zlobin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.08088

2022-03-15

High Energy Physics - Experiment

Abstract:The United States has a rich history in high energy particle accelerators and colliders -- both lepton and hadron machines, which have enabled several major discoveries in elementary particle physics. To ensure continued progress in the field, U.S. leadership as a key partner in building next generation collider facilities abroad is essential; also critically important is the exploring of options to host a future collider in the U.S. The "Snowmass" study and the subsequent Particle Physics Project Prioritization Panel (P5) process provide the timely opportunity to develop strategies for both. What we do now will shape the future of our field and whether the U.S. will remain a world leader in these areas. In this white paper, we briefly discuss the US engagement in proposed collider projects abroad and describe future collider options for the U.S. We also call for initiating an integrated R\&D program for future colliders.
Panel calls for muon collider

Michael Allen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/2058-7058/37/02/11

2024-02-01

Physics World

Abstract:The “P5” panel of US particle physicists say that work on developing a future muon collider could allow the US regain the “energy frontier”, as Michael Allen reveals.

physics, multidisciplinary
The Advanced Superconducting Test Accelerator (ASTA) at Fermilab: A User-Driven Facility Dedicated to Accelerator Science \& Technology

P. Piot,V. Shiltsev,S. Nagaitsev,M. Church,P. Garbincius,S. Henderson,J. Leibfritz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1304.0311

2013-04-01

Abstract:Fermilab is currently constructing a superconducting electron linac that will eventually serve as the backbone of a user-driven facility for accelerator science. This contribution describes the accelerator and summarizes the enabled research thrusts. A detailed description of the facility can be found at [\url{<a class="link-external link-http" href="http://apc.fnal.gov/programs2/ASTA_TEMP/index.shtml" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>}].

Accelerator Physics
Particle Physics in The United States, A Personal View

Sheldon Lee Glashow

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1305.5482

2013-05-24

Abstract:I present my views on the future of America's program in particle physics. I discuss a variety of experimental initiatives that do have the potential to make transformative impacts on our discipline and should be included in our program, as well as others that do not and should not.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Experiment
An 800-MeV superconducting LINAC to support megawatt proton operations at Fermilab

Paul Derwent,Steve Holmes,Valeri Lebedev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1502.01728

2015-02-05

Accelerator Physics

Abstract:Active discussion on the high energy physics priorities in the US carried out since summer of 2013 resulted in changes in Fermilab plans for future development of the existing accelerator complex. In particular, the scope of Project X was reduced to the support of the Long Base Neutrino Facility (LBNF) at the project first stage. The name of the facility was changed to the PIP-II (Proton Improvement Plan). This new facility is a logical extension of the existing Proton Improvement Plan aimed at doubling average power of the Fermilab's Booster and Main Injector (MI). Its design and required R&D are closely related to the Project X. The paper discusses the goals of this new facility and changes to the Project X linac introduced to support the goals.
Novel Approaches to High-Power Proton Beams

Jeffrey Eldred

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2001.05576

2020-01-16

Abstract:The potentially realizable beam power at the Fermilab long-baseline neutrino program has motivated a reinvigorated design and optimization effort for a rapid-cycling synchrotron (RCS) intensity upgrade of the Fermilab proton complex. We examine areas of technological development with the potential for high-impact on the Fermilab RCS design - low-loss slip-stacking, advanced neutrino-target R\&D, laser-stripping H$^{-}$ injection, fast-ramping super-ferric magnets, nonlinear integrable optics, electron lens devices, and next-generation halo monitors. A brief overview is given on the Fermilab Accelerator Science \& Technology (FAST) facility, where the latter three technologies will undergo comprehensive beam tests.

Accelerator Physics
Fermilab's Accelerator Complex: Current Status, Upgrades and Outlook

M.E. Convery

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1612.09287

2016-12-30

Abstract:We report on the status of the Fermilab accelerator complex, including recent performance, upgrades in progress, and plans for the future. Beam delivery to the neutrino experiments surpassed our goals for the past year. The Proton Improvement Plan is well underway with successful 15 Hz beam operation. Beam power of 700 kW to the NOvA experiment was demonstrated and will be routine in the next year. We are also preparing the Muon Campus to commission beam to the g-2 experiment.

Accelerator Physics
Status and Plans for a Superconducting RF Accelerator Test Facility at Fermilab

J. Leibfritz,R. Andrews,C.M. Baffes,K. Carlson,B. Chase,M.D. Church,E.R. Harms,A.L. Klebaner,M. Kucera,A. Martinez,S. Nagaitsev,L.E. Nobrega,P. Piot,J. Reid,M. Wendt,S.J. Wesseln

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1301.6995

2013-01-30

Abstract:The Advanced Superconducting Test Acccelerator (ASTA) is being constructed at Fermilab. The existing New Muon Lab (NML) building is being converted for this facility. The accelerator will consist of an electron gun, injector, beam acceleration section consisting of 3 TTF-type or ILC-type cryomodules, multiple downstream beamlines for testing diagnostics and conducting various beam tests, and a high power beam dump. When completed, it is envisioned that this facility will initially be capable of generating a 750-MeV electron beam with ILC beam intensity. An expansion of this facility was recently completed that will provide the capability to upgrade the accelerator to a total beam energy of 1.5-GeV. Two new buildings were also constructed adjacent to the ASTA facility to house a new cryogenic plant and multiple superconducting RF (SRF) cryomodule test stands. In addition to testing accelerator components, this facility will be used to test RF power systems, instrumentation, and control systems for future SRF accelerators such as the ILC and Project-X. This paper describes the current status and overall plans for this facility.

Accelerator Physics
U.S. National Accelerator R\&D Program on Future Colliders

P. C. Bhat,S. Belomestnykh,A. Bross,S. Dasu,D. Denisov,S. Gourlay,S. Jindariani,A. J. Lankford,S. Nagaitsev,E. A. Nanni,M. A. Palmer,T. Raubenheimer,V. Shiltsev,A. Valishev,C. Vernieri,F. Zimmermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2207.06213

2022-07-13

Abstract:Future colliders are an essential component of a strategic vision for particle physics. Conceptual studies and technical developments for several exciting future collider options are underway internationally. In order to realize a future collider, a concerted accelerator R\&D program is required. The U.S. HEP accelerator R\&D program currently has no direct effort in collider-specific R\&D area. This shortcoming greatly compromises the U.S. leadership role in accelerator and particle physics. In this white paper, we propose a new national accelerator R\&D program on future colliders and outline the important characteristics of such a program.

Accelerator Physics,High Energy Physics - Experiment
New CERN chief pledges to forge ahead with $17-billion supercollider

Davide Castelvecchi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-03666-x

IF: 64.8

2024-11-08

Nature

Abstract:Physicist Mark Thomson will face several challenges — including bringing in enough money to build a colossal new particle-smashing 'Higgs factory'. Physicist Mark Thomson will face several challenges — including bringing in enough money to build a colossal new particle-smashing 'Higgs factory'.

multidisciplinary sciences
Accelerator and Beam Physics: Grand Challenges and Research Opportunities

S. Nagaitsev,V. Shiltsev,A. Valishev,T. Zolkin,J.-L. Vay,M. Bai,Y. Cai,M.J. Hogan,Z. Huang,J. Seeman,B. Dunham,X. Huang,T. Roser,M. Minty,J. Rosenzweig,P. Piot,J. Power,J. M. Byrd,A. Seryi,S. Lund,J. R. Patterson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.06816

2022-03-14

Abstract:Accelerator and beam physics (ABP) is the science of the motion, generation, acceleration, manipulation, prediction, observation and use of charged particle beams. It focuses on fundamental long-term accelerator and beam physics research and development. Accelerator and beam physics research has resulted in important advances in accelerator science, yet support for this research is declining. NSF has terminated its program in accelerator Science and funding by DOE through GARD and Accelerator Stewardship has been steady or declining. The declining support for accelerator research will slow advances and threaten student training and work-force development in accelerator science. We propose a robust and scientifically challenging program in accelerator and beam physics, which will position the field of US High Energy Physics to be productive and competitive for decades to come.

Accelerator Physics,High Energy Physics - Experiment
Panel recommends road map for US particle physics

Toni Feder

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/pt.euqp.udzd

IF: 3.5

2024-02-01

Physics Today

Abstract:The community welcomes the recommendations, recognizing them as fair and balanced within a constrained budget.

physics, multidisciplinary
ASTA at Fermilab: Accelerator Physics and Accelerator Education Programs at the Modern Accelerator R&D Users Facility for HEP and Accelerator Applications

V. Shiltsev,P. Piot

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1409.5445

2014-09-19

Abstract:We present the current and planned beam physics research program and accelerator education program at Advanced Superconducting Test Accelerator (ASTA) at Fermilab.

Accelerator Physics
Enabling Intensity and Energy Frontier Science with a Muon Accelerator Facility in the U.S.: A White Paper Submitted to the 2013 U.S. Community Summer Study of the Division of Particles and Fields of the American Physical Society

J-P. Delahaye,C. Ankenbrandt,A. Bogacz,S. Brice,A. Bross,D. Denisov,E. Eichten,P. Huber,D.M. Kaplan,H. Kirk,R. Lipton,D. Neuffer,M.A. Palmer,R. Palmer,R. Ryne,P. Snopok

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1308.0494

2014-01-04

Abstract:A staged approach towards muon based facilities for Intensity and Energy Frontier science, building upon existing and proposed facilities at Fermilab, is presented. At each stage, a facility exploring new physics also provides an R&D platform to validate the technology needed for subsequent stages. The envisioned program begins with nuSTORM, a sensitive sterile neutrino search which also provides precision neutrino cross-section measurements while developing the technology of using and cooling muons. A staged Neutrino Factory based upon Project X, sending beams towards the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF), which will house the LBNE detector, could follow for detailed exploration of neutrino properties at the Intensity Frontier, while also establishing the technology of using intense bunched muon beams. The complex could then evolve towards Muon Colliders, starting at 126 GeV with measurements of the Higgs resonance to sub-MeV precision, and continuing to multi-TeV colliders for the exploration of physics beyond the Standard Model at the Energy Frontier. An Appendix addresses specific questions raised by the Lepton Colliders subgroup of the CSS2013 Frontier Capabilities Study Group.

Accelerator Physics,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Instrumentation and Detectors
Introduction and Status of Fermilab's ACORN Project

D. Finstrom,E. Gottschalk

2024-01-04

Abstract:Modernizing the Fermilab accelerator control system is essential to future operations of the laboratory's accelerator complex. The existing control system has evolved over four decades and uses hardware that is no longer available and software that uses obsolete frameworks. The Accelerator Controls Operations Research Network (ACORN) Project will modernize the control system and replace end-of-life power supplies to enable future accelerator complex operations with megawatt particle beams. An overview of the ACORN Project and a summary of recent research and development activities will be presented.

Accelerator Physics
US Accelerator R&D Program Toward Intensity Frontier Machines

Vladimir Shiltsev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1612.08751

2016-12-28

Abstract:The 2014 P5 report indicated the accelerator-based neutrino and rare decay physics research as a centrepiece of the US domestic HEP program. Operation, upgrade and development of the accelerators for the near-term and longer-term particle physics program at the Intensity Frontier face formidable challenges. Here we discuss key elements of the accelerator physics and technology R&D program toward future multi-MW proton accelerators.

Accelerator Physics

Leading US particle-physics lab faces uncertain future

Fermilab gets a not-quite-new boss to tackle its troubles

Preparing Fermilab to Carry Out the P5 Plan

Fermilab Program and Plans

Vision to reality: From Robert R. Wilson's frontier to Leon M. Lederman's Fermilab

Future Collider Options for the US

Panel calls for muon collider

The Advanced Superconducting Test Accelerator (ASTA) at Fermilab: A User-Driven Facility Dedicated to Accelerator Science \& Technology

Particle Physics in The United States, A Personal View

An 800-MeV superconducting LINAC to support megawatt proton operations at Fermilab

Novel Approaches to High-Power Proton Beams

Fermilab's Accelerator Complex: Current Status, Upgrades and Outlook

Status and Plans for a Superconducting RF Accelerator Test Facility at Fermilab

U.S. National Accelerator R\&D Program on Future Colliders

New CERN chief pledges to forge ahead with $17-billion supercollider

Accelerator and Beam Physics: Grand Challenges and Research Opportunities

Panel recommends road map for US particle physics

ASTA at Fermilab: Accelerator Physics and Accelerator Education Programs at the Modern Accelerator R&D Users Facility for HEP and Accelerator Applications

Enabling Intensity and Energy Frontier Science with a Muon Accelerator Facility in the U.S.: A White Paper Submitted to the 2013 U.S. Community Summer Study of the Division of Particles and Fields of the American Physical Society

Introduction and Status of Fermilab's ACORN Project

US Accelerator R&D Program Toward Intensity Frontier Machines