Abstract:The Global Action for Measurement of Adolescent health (GAMA) Advisory Group (AG) was established by WHO in collaboration with UN partners in 2018. In line with GAMA’s overarching aim to focus and harmonize global adolescent health measurement, the purpose of this study was to identify specific discrepancies in indicator recommendations promoted by different initiatives and measured through multi-country data collection instruments. First, we identified indicators included in 16 previously identified global initiatives measuring the same concepts as one of the 52 GAMA AG-proposed indicators. Second, we decomposed all indicators into four elements: 1) who: the population of interest, 2) what: the construct or behaviour measured, 3) how much: the threshold, and 4) when: the reference or recall period. Third, we compared the four elements of the GAMA AG-proposed indicators to those of other initiatives including an indicator measuring the same concept. For each initiative indicator element, we coded whether it was 1) an exact match, 2) a partial match, 3) clearly discrepant, or 4) unspecified or ambiguous. Fourth, we reviewed multi-country data collection instruments, using the same four elements to identify whether measurement and tabulation standards aligned with GAMA AG-proposed indicator elements. A total of 179 initiative-recommended indicators were identified that measured the same concept as one of the 52 GAMA AG priority indicators. Five of the GAMA AG-proposed indicators were not covered by any other initiative. Only 16 of the 179 initiative indicators reviewed were an exact match with the corresponding GAMA AG indicator across all elements. Population of interest was the most commonly discrepant element. An exact match to the population of interest was only found in 33 of the 179 reviewed initiative indicators, mainly because the majority of initiatives recommended measurement covering only part of the adolescent age range of 10-19 years. Indicators pertaining to health behaviours and risks were the most likely to be discrepant in terms of the construct, the threshold, and/or the reference period. Indicators with inconsistencies across all these elements included, for example, heavy episodic drinking and tobacco use, and dietary indicators such as fruit and vegetable consumption. Reviewed data collection instruments varied in their methods of measuring and tabulating the indicators. Definitional differences in tobacco use, for example, occurred in the construct (smoking versus any tobacco use), threshold (at least once versus daily), and the reference period (the past 30 days versus an unspecified recall period). The current adolescent measurement landscape is inconsistent, with differing recommendations on what and how to measure. This study highlights specific discrepancies in indicator recommendations across different initiatives promoting what are seemingly the same indicators and links the discrepancies to multi-country data collection instruments. The results provide an empirical basis for improved alignment and harmonization, which can in turn support countries in data collection, interpretation, and use.

Indicators to Measure Adolescent Health at the Country, Regional, and Global Levels: Results of a Five-Year Selection Process by the Global Action for the Measurement of Adolescent Health

Priority Indicators for Adolescent Health Measurement - Recommendations From the Global Action for Measurement of Adolescent Health (GAMA) Advisory Group.

Exploring a Preliminary Set of Indicators to Measure Adolescent Health: Results From a 12-Country Feasibility Study

100. Towards Harmonized Measurement of Adolescent Health: an Assessment of Global-level Indicator Alignment

Towards Harmonized Adolescent Health Measurement: Assessing Alignment Between Current Recommendations and the Global Action for Measurement of Adolescent Health-Recommended Indicators

Challenges and Opportunities to Advance Adolescent Health Measurement in Armenia: Alignment Between Global Priority Indicators and National Policies, and Feasibility of Collecting Sexual, Reproductive, and Mental Health Indicators

Relevance of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to Adolescent Health Measurement: A Systematic Mapping of the SDG Framework and Global Adolescent Health Indicators

Counting Adolescents In: the Development of an Adolescent Health Indicator Framework for Population-Based Settings.

Towards Comprehensive National Surveillance for Adolescent Health in China: Priority Indicators and Current Data Gaps

Examining the recent trends in adolescent sexual and reproductive health in five countries of sub-Saharan Africa based on PMA and DHS household surveys

Consented indicators for the evaluation of integrated strategies of community health promotion targeting children and adolescents: results of an eDelphi

Feasibility of establishing a core set of sexual, reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health indicators in humanitarian settings: results from a multi-methods assessment in Bangladesh

Assessing youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health services: a systematic review

Exploring the feasibility of establishing a core set of sexual, reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health indicators in humanitarian settings: results from a multi-methods assessment in Jordan

Adolescent and youth-friendly health interventions in low-income and middle-income countries: a scoping review

Progress and challenges in implementing adolescent and school health programmes in India: a rapid review

Strategies to improve adolescent health

Feasibility of establishing a core set of sexual, reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health indicators in humanitarian settings: results from a multi-methods assessment in the Democratic Republic of Congo

Measuring adolescent girls' agency

Global school-based student health survey: country profiles and survey results in the eastern Mediterranean region countries

A rapid review of guidelines on the involvement of adolescents in health research