Surgical craft approaches and technologies

Alfred Cuschieri,George Hanna

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1201/b17820-6

2015-01-20

Abstract:Introduction Surgeons require (1) knowledge of the disease processes that they manage; (2) cognitive skills that underline clinical judgement and decision-making; and (3) the necessary level of psychomotor skills to ensure technical operative competence – the ability to perform operations consistently well hence ensuring safety of the patient; therefore, surgery is one of the craft specialties. All of these components of surgical practice are important, but the level of technical competence distinguishes the master surgeon from the average. In psychomotor research, ability is defined as ‘the adaptive capacity, trait, attribute or aptitude that an individual brings to a given task’, whereas skill is the result of a specific combination of abilities reinforced by practice and training. Ability is thus innate and determines the ultimate level of skill that an individual will attain with practice and experience. Performance relates to the overall efficiency with which a complex activity such as a surgical operation is executed. Competence is reached when an individual can perform a task safely, to an acceptable standard and within an acceptable time frame, i.e. the individual can perform the operation safely and with good patient outcome, but is still acquiring experience in executing the procedure and has to use what the ergonomic psychologist calls ‘control active mode’ throughout. Proficiency indicates that competence is consistent and has reached the ‘expert level’ as a result of experience and reinforcement by a sustained caseload. This is the level that every surgical trainee must achieve as an independent consultant. In achieving proficiency, the surgical trainee progresses though a proficiencygain curve that is as specific to an operation as it is to the individual trainee. Proficiency gain requires supervised training by a tutor assisting the trainee and reinforcement, i.e. perform the same operation (caseload effect) until the proficiency plateau (Figure 2.1) is reached, when surgeons attain the semiautonomic operating mode, i.e. they can do the operation without having to think of the various steps of the procedure. Unfortunately, the proficiency-gain curve is often erroneously called the learning curve, but the two are not equivalent. Learning refers to acquisition of knowledge of the indications for the operation, the component tasks and steps of the procedure, the instruments and technologies required to do the operation, etc., but gives no indication that the individual can actually do the operation.