Optimizing laparoscopic and robotic skills through simulation in participants with limited or no prior experience: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Doris Sarmiento-Altamirano,Fernanda Ormaza,María Rosa Arroyo,Catherine Cabrera-Ordoñez,Rafael Valdivieso,Megan Docksey,Salomone Di Saverio
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gassur.2024.01.027
2024-01-01
Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery
Abstract:Background Simulation is an innovative tool for developing complex skills required for surgical training. The objective of this study is to determine the advancement of laparoscopic and robotic skills through simulation in participants with limited or no prior experience. Methods This is a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCT) in keeping with according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. We conducted searches using MEDLINE (PubMed), Web of Science, Google Scholar and COCHRANE library. Variables analyzed were: study characteristics, participant demographics, characteristics of the learning program. Our main measures were: effectiveness, surgical time, errors. These were reported using standardized mean difference (SDM). 95% CI (p < 0.05). Secondary measures included skill transfer and learning curve. Results 17 RCTs were included and comprised 619 participants total: 354 (57%) participants were in the simulation group and 265 (43%) in the control group. Results indicated that laparoscopic simulation effectively enhanced surgical skills [SMD, 0.59 (0.18,1); p =0.004] and was significantly associated with shorter surgical duration [SMD, -1.08 (-1.57,-0.59) p =<0.0001] and fewer errors made [SMD, -1.91(-3.13,-0.70) p =0.002]. In the robotic simulation there was no difference in effectiveness [SMD, 0.17 (-0.19,0.52); p =0.36] or surgical time [SMD, 0.27 (-0.86,1.39) p =0.64]. Furthermore, skills were found to be transferable from simulation to a real-life operating room (p = <0.05). Conclusion Simulation is an effective tool for optimizing laparoscopic skills, even in participants with limited or no prior experience. This approach not only contributes to the reduction of surgical time and errors but also facilitates the transfer of skills to the surgical environment. In contrast, robotic simulation fails to maximize skill development, requiring prior experience in laparoscopy to achieve optimal levels of effectiveness.
gastroenterology & hepatology,surgery