Abstract:<p>With recent developments in computational techniques, Data-driven Machine Learning Models (DMLs) have shown great potential in simulating streamflow and capturing the rainfall-runoff relationship in given watersheds, which are traditionally fulfilled by Process-based Hydrologic Models (PHMs). There are debates on whether the DMLs can outperform and possibly replace the classical PHMs for streamflow simulation and river forecasting, but no clear conclusions have been made. This study aims to investigate whether the newer DMLs have any potential in further improving the simulation accuracy of classical PHMs, and vice versa. To do this, we compared a few popular PHMs and DMLs over four watersheds across the Continental US (CONUS) that are associated with different input, climate, and regional conditions. A total of five hydrologic models were chosen, including (1) two classical lumped models, i.e., the Sacramento Soil Moisture Accounting (SAC-SMA) and Xinanjiang (XAJ); (2) one modern distributed model, termed Coupled Routing and Excess Storage (CREST); (3) and two DMLs including an Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) and a deep learning model, termed Long Short Term Memory (LSTM). Our results demonstrated that the DMLs still significantly biased when using the baseline input scenario with the PHMs. However, the DMLs fed with delayed input scenarios had great potential and can reach high simulation accuracy. The DMLs, especially the ANN, outperformed other employed models under the rainfall-runoff relationship in which rainfall dominantly drives. The DMLs also showed better performance in the high-flow regime, while the PHMs had a better performance for the low-flow regime, implying both PHMs and DMLs have their own merits and are worthy of joint development. In general, our study indicated a great potential of using DMLs to simulate streamflow, but further studies are still needed to verify the transferability and scalability of DMLs in large-scale experiments, such as the Distributed Model Intercomparison Projects 1&2 conducted by National Weather Services but to compare modern DMLs and PHMs.</p>

On the need for physical constraints in deep learning rainfall–runoff projections under climate change: a sensitivity analysis to warming and shifts in potential evapotranspiration

Appropriateness of Potential Evapotranspiration Models for Climate Change Impact Analysis in Yarlung Zangbo River Basin, China

Using Physics-Encoded GeoAI to Improve the Physical Realism of Deep Learning′s Rainfall-Runoff Responses under Climate Change

Developing a Physics-Informed Deep Learning Model to Simulate Runoff Response to Climate Change in Alpine Catchments

Changes in Spatio-temporal Precipitation Patterns in Changing Climate Conditions

Rainfall Manipulation Experiments As Simulated by Terrestrial Biosphere Models: Where Do We Stand?

Revisiting evapotranspiration inputs in eco-hydrological modeling for climate change assessment

Climate warming effects in stratified reservoirs: Thorough assessment for opportunities and limits of machine learning techniques versus process-based models in thermal structure projections

Do Model Parameters Change under Changing Climate and Land Use in the Upstream of the Lancang River Basin, China?

The suitability of differentiable, physics-informed machine learning hydrologic models for ungauged regions and climate change impact assessment

Assessing the Ability of Potential Evaporation Models to Capture the Sensitivity to Temperature

Can artificial intelligence and data-driven machine learning models match or even replace process-driven hydrologic models for streamflow simulation?: A case study of four watersheds with different hydro-climatic regions across the CONUS

Future Climatic Projections and Hydrological Responses with a Data Driven Method: A Regional Climate Model Perspective

Evaluating Deep Learning Approaches for Predictions in Unmonitored Basins with Continental-scale Stream Temperature Models

A process-driven deep learning hydrological model for daily rainfall-runoff simulation

Deep learning rainfall-runoff predictions of extreme events

Capabilities of deep learning models on learning physical relationships: Case of rainfall-runoff modeling with LSTM

Comparing machine learning and deep learning models for probabilistic post-processing of satellite precipitation-driven streamflow simulation

Watershed-Scale, Probabilistic Risk Assessment of Water Resources Impacts from Climate Change

Deep dive into hydrologic simulations at global scale: harnessing the power of deep learning and physics-informed differentiable models (δHBV-globe1.0-hydroDL)

Differentiable, learnable, regionalized process-based models with physical outputs can approach state-of-the-art hydrologic prediction accuracy