Less in the West: The tangibility of international organizations and their media visibility around the world

Michal Parizek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11558-024-09551-6

2024-05-31

The Review of International Organizations

Abstract:This paper presents the first theoretical and large-scale empirical account of the visibility of major global international organizations (IOs) in news media around the world. It focuses on the everyday, continuous coverage of IOs, through which knowledge and support of IOs can be built over time. Synthesizing insights from Media Studies and International Relations (IR), I develop a theoretical framework centered on the tangibility of IOs' work—its concreteness and proximity to audiences—as the key driver of variation in IOs' media visibility across states. Empirically, I study the media visibility of the 40 IOs and IO bodies that form the UN System broadly defined, including virtually all the major formal global IOs. I find that the IOs are systematically more visible in states where they conduct tangible development-focused operational activity. The differences are sizeable: IO media visibility in states with the lowest levels of human development is approximately 75% higher than in highest-development level states, typically Western. The empirical analysis is based on a novel dataset of more than 3.4 million news articles in 63 languages and 135 states, accounting for 96% of the world population, spanning 2018–2021. Natural language processing-based analysis is complemented with human coding of the content of a sample of articles, further highlighting the importance of the development-focused operational activity of IOs for their media visibility. The findings have important implications for our understanding of the public image of IOs in Western states and beyond.

economics,international relations,political science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main issue this paper attempts to address is the visibility differences of international organizations (IOs) in the news media of different countries and the reasons behind these differences. Specifically:

1. **Theoretical Framework and Empirical Research**: The paper proposes a theoretical framework that combines insights from media studies and international relations, focusing on how the specificity of the work content of international organizations and their proximity to the audience (i.e., "tangibility") drive their media visibility. By analyzing more than 3.4 million articles from 135 countries and 63 languages between 2018 and 2021, the authors find that the media coverage frequency of international organizations is significantly higher in low-income countries compared to high-income countries.

2. **Specific Hypothesis**: The core hypothesis of the paper is that media coverage of international organizations is more prevalent in countries where they are actively engaged in development aid activities. For example, many agencies within the United Nations system have significantly higher media exposure in low-income countries than in Western developed countries.

3. **Supplementary Hypotheses**: In addition to the core hypothesis, the paper also explores other potential factors that might influence the media visibility of international organizations, such as the degree of a country's integration into the global economy and the type of political system. However, these factors did not receive empirical support.

In summary, this paper aims to reveal the patterns of media visibility of international organizations globally and empirically test its theoretical hypotheses. This helps to understand the mechanisms of public perception and support for international organizations.