Abstract:Purpose/Objective(s)The optimization of energy layer distributions is crucial for efficient proton ARC therapy: on one hand, a sufficient number of energy layers is needed to ensure the plan quality; on the other hand, an excess number of energy jumps can substantially slow down the treatment delivery. This work will develop a new treatment plan optimization method with direct minimization of number of energy jumps (NEJ), which will be shown to outperform state-of-the-art methods in both plan quality and delivery efficiency.Materials/MethodsThe proposed method jointly optimizes the plan quality and minimizes the NEJ. To minimize NEJ, (1) the proton spots x is summed per energy layer to form the energy vector y; (2) y is binarized via sigmoid transform into y1; (3) y1 is multiplied with a predefined energy order vector via dot product into y2; (4) y2 is filtered through the finite-differencing kernel into y3 in order to identify NEJ; (5) only the NEJ of y3 is penalized, while x is optimized for plan quality. The solution algorithm to this new method is based on iterative convex relaxation.ResultsThe new method is validated in comparison with state-of-the-art methods called energy sequencing (ES) method and energy matrix (EM) method. In terms of delivery efficiency, the new method had fewer NEJ, less energy switching time, and generally less total delivery time. In terms of plan quality, the new method had smaller optimization objective values, lower normal tissue dose, and generally better target coverage. A head-and-neck case is provided in the table with the following dosimetric parameters: planning objective value F; conformity index CI; homogeneity index HI; mean dose of larynx DOAR; mean body dose Dbody; the unit of dose is Gy.ConclusionWe have developed a new treatment plan optimization method with direct minimization of NEJ, and demonstrated that this new method outperformed state-of-the-art methods (ES and EM) in both plan quality and delivery efficiency. The optimization of energy layer distributions is crucial for efficient proton ARC therapy: on one hand, a sufficient number of energy layers is needed to ensure the plan quality; on the other hand, an excess number of energy jumps can substantially slow down the treatment delivery. This work will develop a new treatment plan optimization method with direct minimization of number of energy jumps (NEJ), which will be shown to outperform state-of-the-art methods in both plan quality and delivery efficiency. The proposed method jointly optimizes the plan quality and minimizes the NEJ. To minimize NEJ, (1) the proton spots x is summed per energy layer to form the energy vector y; (2) y is binarized via sigmoid transform into y1; (3) y1 is multiplied with a predefined energy order vector via dot product into y2; (4) y2 is filtered through the finite-differencing kernel into y3 in order to identify NEJ; (5) only the NEJ of y3 is penalized, while x is optimized for plan quality. The solution algorithm to this new method is based on iterative convex relaxation. The new method is validated in comparison with state-of-the-art methods called energy sequencing (ES) method and energy matrix (EM) method. In terms of delivery efficiency, the new method had fewer NEJ, less energy switching time, and generally less total delivery time. In terms of plan quality, the new method had smaller optimization objective values, lower normal tissue dose, and generally better target coverage. A head-and-neck case is provided in the table with the following dosimetric parameters: planning objective value F; conformity index CI; homogeneity index HI; mean dose of larynx DOAR; mean body dose Dbody; the unit of dose is Gy. We have developed a new treatment plan optimization method with direct minimization of NEJ, and demonstrated that this new method outperformed state-of-the-art methods (ES and EM) in both plan quality and delivery efficiency.

Simultaneous reduction of number of spots and energy layers in intensity modulated proton therapy for rapid spot scanning delivery

Simultaneous Reduction of Number of Spots and Energy Layers in Intensity Modulated Proton Therapy for Rapid Spot Scanning Delivery

Improving Delivery Efficiency Using Spots and Energy Layers Reduction Algorithms Based on a Large Momentum Acceptance Beamline

Plan-Delivery-Time-Constrained Inverse Optimization for High-Throughput PBS Proton RT

Proton energy optimization and reduction for intensity-modulated proton therapy.

A New Treatment Planning Method for Efficient Proton ARC Therapy with Direct Minimization of Number of Energy Jumps

Combined optimization of spot positions and weights for better FLASH proton therapy

A Treatment Plan Optimization Method with Direct Minimization of Number of Energy Jumps for Proton Arc Therapy.

Cardinality‐constrained plan‐quality and delivery‐time optimization method for proton therapy

Effect of the initial energy layer and spot placement parameters on IMPT delivery efficiency and plan quality

Optimizing spot intensity with lower bound constraints for IMPT: Exposing shortcomings and introducing an enhanced strategy

Technical Note: Plan-delivery-time Constrained Inverse Optimization Method with Minimum-Mu-per-energy-layer (MMPEL) for Efficient Pencil Beam Scanning Proton Therapy.

Energy Layer Optimization Via Energy Matrix Regularization for Proton Spot-Scanning Arc Therapy

Robust Optimization for Intensity-Modulated Proton Therapy with Soft Spot Sensitivity Regularization

TVL1-IMPT: Optimization of Peak-to-Valley Dose Ratio Via Joint Total-Variation and L1 Dose Regularization for Spatially Fractionated Pencil-Beam-Scanning Proton Therapy

Improving IMRT delivery efficiency with reweighted L1‐minimization for inverse planning

Proton arc therapy plan optimization with energy layer pre-selection driven by organ at risk sparing and delivery time

A novel fast robust optimization algorithm for intensity-modulated proton therapy with minimum monitor unit constraint

An Iterative Convex Relaxation Method for Proton LET Optimization

Technical note: Optimizing spot‐scanning proton arc therapy with a novel spot sparsity approach

A New Approach to Improve Imrt Delivery Efficiency by Intensity Map Discretization