Rapid screening of multi-point mutations for enzyme thermostability modification by utilizing computational tools

Jia Jin,Qiaozhen Meng,Min Zeng,Guihua Duan,Ercheng Wang,Fei Guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.future.2024.06.034
IF: 7.307
2024-06-22
Future Generation Computer Systems
Abstract:Enzymes play an important role in industry due to their catalytic properties and environmental friendliness. For application in harsh industrial environments, enzymes are modified to obtain improved stability through simultaneous mutations at multiple sites. Contrary to experimental methods, computational methods are significantly more efficient and cost-effective for screening stabilizing mutations. However, there is no systematic evaluation of multi-point mutation predictors for enzyme applications. In this study, we investigate the computational methods that are published for multi-point mutation stability change and select four representative ones: DDGun, MAESTRO, DynaMut2 and DDMut. To evaluate their performance comprehensively, we collected three benchmark datasets with different numbers of mutation sites and three enzyme-only datasets, utilizing RMSE and PCC as metrics. Then, we compare their ability to identify stabilizing ( ΔΔ G¿0) and destabilizing ( ΔΔ G¡0) variants. Meanwhile, we analyze the robustness of four predictors by testing their prediction biases on stabilizing and destabilizing variants. The results of the above tasks indicate that DDMut displays exceptional efficiency among all predictors. Furthermore, to explore the availability of four predictors on enzyme modification, we gather 167 IsPETase variants and 34 leaf-branch compost cutinase (LCC) variants from the literature. DDGun achieves the highest Recall on both single-point and multi-point mutations of them. We also evaluate the four predictors from the perspective of amino acid hydrophobicity and charge change at the mutation site. Overall, DDGun is the optimal choice for enzyme thermostability modification and DDMut can also be taken into consideration. We hope our work can guide enzyme engineering in various mutation scenarios.
computer science, theory & methods
What problem does this paper attempt to address?