Abstract:Selective mutism (SM) is a poorly understood condition, and debate continues regarding its etiology and classification. Research suggests that a genetic vulnerability may play a role in the development of the disorder which may be compounded by anxious and over-protective parenting. While previous studies supported the role of parenting styles in the development of SM, most of them examined child and parent factors in isolation. The current study examined how the interactions between child internalizing and externalizing behaviors (anxiety and oppositionality, respectively) and parenting styles (authoritative, permissive, and authoritarian) are associated with SM diagnosis. The study included 285 children aged 3–7 years (57.2% females), and their parents (66 children with SM and 219 typically developed children). Parents completed questionnaires about child social anxiety, oppositional behavior, SM severity, and their parenting style. Results showed that parents of children with SM reported lower levels of authoritative practices than those of typically developed children. We also found that child social anxiety and oppositionality moderated the effects of authoritative and authoritarian parenting practices on SM diagnosis. Our results suggest that child anxiety and oppositionality may explain the different susceptibility of children to adaptive and maladaptive parenting styles.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the causes of Selective Mutism (SM) and its relationship with parenting styles. Specifically, the study aims to explore how the interaction between children's internalizing behaviors (such as anxiety) and externalizing behaviors (such as oppositional behavior) with three types of parenting styles (authoritative, permissive, and authoritarian) influences the diagnosis of SM. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **The relationship between children's SM and anxiety and oppositional behavior**: The study hypothesizes that children with SM will exhibit higher levels of social anxiety and oppositional behavior. 2. **The relationship between parenting styles and SM**: The study hypothesizes that parents of children with SM will more frequently adopt authoritarian and permissive parenting styles, and less frequently adopt authoritative parenting styles. 3. **The moderating role of children's anxiety and oppositional behavior in the relationship between parenting styles and SM diagnosis**: The study hypothesizes that the levels of children's anxiety and oppositional behavior will moderate the relationship between parenting styles and SM diagnosis, particularly that children with high anxiety and high oppositional behavior are more likely to be diagnosed with SM under authoritarian and permissive parenting styles. ### Research Background: Selective Mutism (SM) is a psychological disorder characterized by a persistent inability to speak in specific social situations, despite being able to communicate normally in other settings. Although research on SM has been increasing, its etiology and classification remain controversial. Studies suggest that genetic susceptibility, anxiety, and overprotective parenting may play significant roles in the development of SM. However, most previous research has primarily focused on either child or parent factors, neglecting the interaction between the two. ### Research Methods: - **Participants**: 285 children aged 3-7 years (66 diagnosed with SM and 219 typically developing children) and their parents. - **Measurement Tools**: Including the Child Anxiety Scale, Child Behavior Checklist, and Parenting Styles Questionnaire. - **Data Analysis**: Independent sample t-tests, Pearson correlation analysis, and conditional process modeling were used to analyze the data. ### Research Results: - **Children's Age and Family Income**: Children in the SM group were slightly older than those in the control group, but there was no significant difference in family income. - **SM Symptoms and Social Anxiety**: Children in the SM group had significantly higher levels of social anxiety than those in the control group, and their parents reported less use of authoritative parenting styles. - **Relationship between Parenting Styles and SM**: Authoritative parenting style and children's anxiety had main effects on the diagnosis of SM, and the interaction between authoritative parenting style and children's anxiety was significant. Additionally, the three-way interaction among these factors was significant, indicating that authoritative parenting style significantly reduced the probability of SM diagnosis in children with high anxiety and moderate to high oppositional behavior. ### Conclusion: The results support the moderating role of children's anxiety and oppositional behavior in the relationship between parenting styles and SM diagnosis. Specifically, children with high anxiety and moderate to high oppositional behavior are less likely to be diagnosed with SM under authoritative parenting styles, but more likely to be diagnosed with SM under authoritarian and permissive parenting styles. These findings contribute to understanding the complex mechanisms of SM and provide a theoretical basis for future interventions.

Interactions between parenting styles, child anxiety, and oppositionality in selective mutism

Phasic Versus Tonic Irritability and Associations with Family Accommodation Among Youth with Selective Mutism: A Latent Profile Analysis

Symptoms of selective mutism beyond failure to speak in children and adolescents

A Review on Pediatric Social Phobia and Selective Mutism

Anxiety Is Associated With DPPIV Alterations in Children With Selective Mutism and Social Anxiety Disorder: A Pilot Study

Is autonomic functioning distinctly associated with anxiety and unsociability in preschoolers?

Bidirectional and interactive effects of child temperament and parenting in early childhood on the trajectory of social anxiety in adolescence

Including children with selective mutism in mainstream schools and kindergartens: problems and possibilities

Parenting Characteristics among Adults With Social Anxiety and their Influence on Social Anxiety Development in Children: A Brief Integrative Review

Preschoolers’ genetic, physiological, and behavioral sensitivity factors moderate links between parenting stress and child internalizing, externalizing, and sleep problems

Parents’ attachment anxiety and preoccupation with their child’s social functioning: The moderating role of social rejection and acceptance

Association between Mothers' Emotional Problems and Autistic Children's Behavioral Problems: The Moderating Effect of Parenting Style

A narrative review of the relationship between parenting and anxiety disorders in children and adolescents

The Role of Children's Neurophysiological Functioning in the Links Between Emotion-Parenting Behaviors and Child Anxiety Symptoms: A Biological Sensitivity to Context Framework

Parental Overprotection and Locus of Control as the Mechanisms Explaining the Relationship Between Parent and Child Anxiety: A Multiple Mediation Model

Differences in sensitivity to parenting depending on child temperament: A meta-analysis.

Child–parent agreement on the SDQ: The role of child–parent attachment and parental feelings

Family process and child anxiety and aggression: An observational analysis

School Refusal Behaviors: The Roles of Adolescent and Parental Factors

Fearful Temperament and Child Social Anxiety Symptoms: Clarifying the Influence of Maternal Punitive Responses

Parenting Interacts with Oxytocin Polymorphisms to Predict Adolescent Social Anxiety Symptom Development: A Novel Polygenic Approach