Exclusionism in American Geography

B. Thomas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/PCG.1962.0010

2014-10-01

Abstract:One of the characteristics of geography in America has been the tendency to ignore or reject certain types of geography; that is, to more or less exclude them from consideration in the inner circles of the profession. Exclusionism, Type I, refers to the ignoring or granting of only halfhearted support to school geography by university people. It is true that work on educational geography is not highly esteemed by some researchoriented universities and that the profession has need of concentrated research efforts along many lines of scholarly investigation. However, many university professors in respected fields such as history, chemistry, English, and foreign languages have, for many years, considered it appropriate to give attention to the status of their subjects in secondary schools in order to raise high school standards and provide better preparation for the university. The American Historical Association, for example, appointed its first committee to deal with the teaching of history in the schools in 18961 before the Association of American Geographers was established, and has continued to be interested to the present time. The recent involvement of the Association of American Geographers in a program to improve high school geography is a helpful step in the right direction. It is to be hoped that Exclusionism, Type I., will be much less common in the near future. Surely, with the present talent we have in the American geographic profession, it is not impossible to have excellence in the high school as well as on the graduate research level. Exclusionism, Type IL, involves the idea of a profession dominated by university teaching and research, with geographers in government and business excluded or relegated to a marginal role. This practice, along with others, was defeated as a policy by the merger of the American Society for Professional Geographers with the Association of American Geographers in 1948. Since then, geographers from outside the universities have been increasingly involved in the affairs of the Association. On three recent occasions, geographers who have spent much of their careers with the government have been honored by election to the presidency. These men, of course, are Louis Quam, Paul Siple, and Arch Gerlach. This is a further indication that Exclusionism, Type IL, is no longer the divisive, weakening force it once was.

Geography