Abstract:For doctoral students, publishing in peer-reviewed journals is a task many face with anxiety and trepidation. The world of publishing, from choosing a journal, negotiating with editors and navigating reviewers' responses is a bewildering place. Looking in from the outside, it seems that successful and productive academic writers have knowledge that is inaccessible to novice scholars. While there is a growing literature on writing for scholarly publication, many of these publications promote writing and publishing as a straightforward activity that anyone can achieve if they follow the rules. We argue that the specific and situated contexts in which academic writers negotiate publishing practices is more complicated and messy. In this paper, we attempt to make explicit our publishing processes to highlight the complex nature of publishing. We use autoethnographic narratives to provide discussion points and insights into the challenges of publishing peer reviewed articles. One narrative is by a doctoral student at the beginning of her publishing career, who expresses her desires, concerns and anxieties about writing for publication. The other narrative focuses on the publishing practices of a more experienced academic writer. Both are international scholars working in the Canadian context. The purpose of this paper is to explore academic publishing through the juxtaposition of these two narratives to make explicit some of the more implicit processes. Four themes emerge from these narratives. To publish successfully, academic writers need: (1) to be discourse analysts; (2) to have a critical competence; (3) to have writing fluency; and (4) to be emotionally intelligent.

Publishing as an Agricultural Economist: Thoughts on Why, Where and How

A Pragmatic Approach to Getting Published: 35 Tips for Early Career Researchers

Publishing in high quality journals: perspectives from overworked and unpaid reviewers

Publishing an applied statistics paper: Guidance and advice from editors

Assessing research output quality in agricultural economics

Academic Publishing: Making the Implicit Explicit

Developing and Publishing Strong Empirical Research in Sustainability Management—Addressing the Intersection of Theory, Method, and Empirical Field

Writing a better research article

Why is so Harder to Write and Publish Academic Papers?

How to Write and Publish a Research Paper for a Peer-Reviewed Journal

How to Write and Publish Quality Articles? Insights for Early-Stage Researchers

Publishing Research in China: History, Characteristics, and Challenges

Beyond Journals and Peer Review: Towards a More Flexible Ecosystem for Scholarly Communication

Journeying Through Journals: The Publishing Process and How to Maximise Research Impact

The Practical Journal Article: Writing to Be Read by Professionals in the Field

Writing and publishing a scientific paper

Writing like a scientist: a research assignment for undergraduates inspired by the publishing process

Beyond publishing primary research papers

Publishing Biomedical Research: a rapidly evolving ecosystem

Scientific research article – How to write and get it published?

The ART and LOGIC of scholarly communication: Effective skills for publication and beyond