Deconstructing Sartre

Alfred Betschart

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3167/ssi.2022.280106

2022-06-01

Sartre Studies International

Abstract:François Noudelmann, Un tout autre Sartre (Paris: Gallimard, 2020), 206 pp. ISBN 978-2-07-288710-9. €18/e-book €13.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The intelligibility of history (unfinished)/ Jean-Paul Sartre ; edited by Arlette Elkaïm-Sartre ; translated by Quintin Hoare

J. Sartre,Arlette Elkaïm-Sartre

Abstract:At the height of the Algerian war, Jean-Paul Sartre embarked on a fundamental reappraisal of his philosophical and political thought. The result was the "Critique of Dialectical Reason," an intellectual masterpiece of the twentieth century, now published as a two-volume set with a major new introduction by Fredric Jameson. In it, Sartre set out the basic categories for the renovated theory of history that he believed was necessary for post-war Marxism. Sartre's formal aim was to establish the dialectical intelligibility of history itself, as what he called 'a totalisation without a totaliser'. But, at the same time, his substantive concern was the structure of class struggle and the fate of mass movements of popular revolt, from the French Revolution at the end of the eighteenth century to the Russian and Chinese revolutions in the twentieth: their ascent, stabilisation, petrification and decline, in a world still overwhelmingly dominated by scarcity. The second volume of Sartre's Critique of Dialectical Reason was drafted in 1958 and published in France in 1985, first appearing in English in 1991. As in Volume One, Sartre proceeds by moving from the simple to the complex: from individual combat (through a perceptive study of boxing) to the struggle of subgroups within an organized group form and, finally, to social struggle, with an extended analysis of the Bolshevik Revolution. The book concludes with a forceful reaffirmation of dialectical reason: of the dialectic as 'that which is truly irreducible in action'.

History,Philosophy
On "intertextuality" of Sartre's Literary Writings

刘成富

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-722x.2004.04.021

2004-01-01

Abstract:French existentialist philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre has initiated a new way of writing by combining literary images and philosophy thoughts. From discovering the absurd to leaving off the absurd, from rising in revolt to taking a free choice, from giving up novel and theater writing to endorsing informal essays, Sartre has passed from negation to negation. However, through a study of themes of his works, we find that intertextualityis one of the most important characteristics of his writings.
SARTRE, BOURDIEU, AND GUSTAVE FLAUBERT: FROM INDIVIDUAL FREEDOM AND SOCIAL DETERMINISM IN THE FIELD OF LITERARY CREATION

Emma Barrett Fiedler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46827/ejls.v3i1.280

2021-08-27

European Journal of Literary Studies

Abstract:Drawing from the analysis of Sartre’s monumental biography of the French writer Gustave Flaubert and Bourdieu’s critical response to it, this article explores anew the dialectics of agency and coercion through the lenses of sartrian philosophy and bourdieusian sociology. From his birth to his childhood and his death in 1880, the biographical elements of the life of Madame Bovary’s author and the contents of his literary works were depicted by Sartre and Bourdieu in a dialogue questioning the writer’s individual goals, strategies, limits and fate. Put in a historical perspective, this socio-philosophical confrontation between the theoretical aims and methods of existentialist psychoanalysis and structuralist socio-analysis reopens the oldest of debates between actor-centered philosophy of action and socio-centered logic of practice, between the transcendence of ego and the transcendence of social, or freedom and determinism. Article visualizations:
Nonverbal Communication, Silence and Cultural expressions in Jean-Paul Sartre’s literary Concept: A Philosophical Language and Art View

DOI: https://doi.org/10.57125/fp.2024.09.30.04

2024-06-22

Abstract:Existing scholarship on Jean-Paul Sartre's literary works predominantly discussed his overarching philosophy of existentialism with extra attention given to his political activism and reflections on Marxism, colonialism and social justice. However, the investigation of nonverbal communication in his literary creations remains a relatively unexplored area in academic discourse. The study addressed this gap by analysing the symbolic meanings conveyed through characters' nonverbal cues, specifically, body language, gestures, facial expressions and spatial dynamics in Sartre’s (1944) play “Huis clos”. The research methodology entailed a comprehensive examination of nonverbal communication in the study’s sample text. This analysis involved a combination of qualitative and textual approaches. Qualitative methods were utilised to interpret and understand the symbolic meanings conveyed through nonverbal cues such as body language, gestures, facial expressions, and spatial dynamics. Textual analysis involved a detailed examination of the play's dialogue and stage directions to identify instances of nonverbal communication and their significance within the context of the narrative. Grounded in semiotics and existentialist theory, the study aimed to assess cultural expressions and literary interpretations one how nonverbal cues and moments of silence contributed to character development, and thematic examination in the play. The study findings reveal that nonverbal communication, which included gestures, facial expressions, and body language, served as a significant source of meaning and symbolism in literature. The analysis identified ways in which nonverbal elements reinforced and articulated Sartre’s philosophical perspectives, and exposed interpersonal dynamics among humans. Also, the study unravelled symbolic meanings and adds a unique layer to the assimilation of Sartre’s concepts and its implications on human relationships. The study's contribution lies in its focused examination of nonverbal communication, which enriches scholarly discourse in contemporary society.
The Specter of Sartre in Brazilian Concrete Poetry: Paideuma, Affect, Politics, and the Question of World Literature

Adam Joseph Shellhorse

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/rhm.2023.a913730

2023-12-01

Revista Hispánica Moderna

Abstract:ABSTRACT: This essay returns to Brazilian concrete poetry's origins and conception of the paideuma. It does so in order to unearth the cardinal, yet underestimated legacy of Jean-Paul Sartre for the Noigandres group's conception of poetic form, literary engagement, and world literature. Drawing on their theoretical writings as well as those of Sartre, Martin Heidegger, Oswald de Andrade, Ernest Fenollosa and Pound, I illustrate how the French thinker configured a matrical part of what the poets deemed the cultural-morphological process. Third, against the grain of the numerous critiques that have shortchanged the concretes' participatory experiments, the essay endeavors to throw light over the intervening power of their political poetics, concluding with an assessment of Haroldo de Campos's "poemalivro," Servidão de passagem (1962). By way of a return to antropofagia, the ideogram, and the Poundian paideuma, I show how Campos's breakthrough shatters "the Sartrean dilemma" and alters the theory and practice of committed literature, configuring itself as a generative, constellatory, and mediational praxis for counterconstructing the present (H. Campos, "Respuesta" 43).
A truncated manuscript

Pierre Schapira

DOI: https://doi.org/10.37282/991819.22.61

2023-01-08

Abstract:A critical essay of the book ``Récoltes et Semailles'' by Alexander Grothendieck, recently published by Gallimard editions.

History and Overview
À propos des Inséparables de Simone de Beauvoir

Philippe Devaux

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/25897616-bja10035

2022-04-21

Simone de Beauvoir Studies

Abstract:Résumé La parution posthume des Inséparables invite à distinguer les deux modalités d’ écriture par lesquelles Beauvoir a fait revivre la figure majeure pour elle de Zaza (1907-1929), son amie d’ enfance et de jeunesse : la fiction puis l’ autobiographie ; et cela à la lumière des appréciations de l’ autrice et du pacte de lecture propre à chaque modalité d’ écriture. Ces approches successives sur plusieurs décennies témoignent de la fascination constante de Beauvoir pour Zaza et incitent le lecteur à prolonger l’ exploration beauvoirienne par les écrits mêmes de Zaza.
Questioning Cézanne across Sightlines: Balzac, Zola, and Merleau-Ponty

Véronique M. Fóti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/h11020056

2022-04-14

Humanities

Abstract:Although Merleau-Ponty’s privileging of Cézanne in the context of his philosophy of painting does not explicitly address the painter’s relation to literature, this relation is important and somewhat problematic. Cézanne was an avid reader of both classical Latin and contemporary French literature, but he sought, in his maturity, to dissociate painting from the inspiration of literature. The danger of a mode of figurative painting informed by literature is explored in Balzac’s novella The Unknown Masterpiece, of which there are echoes in Merleau-Ponty’s discussions of painting, and which is alluded to in Emile Zola’s novel The Masterpiece, which led Cézanne to break off his lifelong friendship with the author. Zola’s novel contradicts Merleau-Ponty’s emphasis on the artist’s creative freedom by portraying his protagonist, modeled on Cézanne, as destroyed by a fatality of destiny. Cézanne, in his maturity, sought to conjoin in painting a “logic of the eyes” with a “logic of the brain” resulting in an art genuinely “parallel with nature”, which it sought to express rather than to represent. The article explores this dissociation of painting from literature and autonomy with respect to what Merleau-Ponty calls “the dimension of color” and to Cézanne’s lifelong theme of bathers in a landscape.
Sartre Studies in China: from the New Period to the New Century

Song Xuezhi,Xu Jun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11702-007-0013-7

2007-01-01

Frontiers of Literary Studies in China

Abstract:This essay, from four aspects of initiation study, author study, textual study and drama study, attempts to make a comprehensive, systematic and concise survey of the enormous research on Sartre and his existentialist literature done in China from the new period to the new century. Meanwhile, it also makes an objective analysis of the problems arising in the studying process, and offers constructive suggestions for future studies.
Françoise Lavocat (a cura di) La théorie littéraire des mondes possibles

Guido Furci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13125/2039-6597/590

2012-06-26

Abstract:I testi raccolti ed introdotti da Francoise Lavocat nel suo La theorie litteraire des mondes possibile (2010) ambiscono tutti a colmare una lacuna. Quella causata dal cosiddetto tournant cognitiviste , caratterizzato dal consolidarsi di un dialogo fra scienze umane e scienze esatte – nell’intento, certo, di ridurre lo scarto fra ambiti disciplinari distinti, seppur accomunati da uno stesso interesse per il lascito post-strutturalista –, ma anche promotore di una politica editoriale senza precedenti, destinata ad escludere dal canone contemporaneo buona parte di quei contributi, il cui punto di forza non potesse consistere nell’ulteriore avanzamento della rivoluzione epistemologica in corso.

Art
Claude Maisonnier. La Chapelle de Ronchamp, naissance d’un chef-d’œuvre

Guillemette Morel Journel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4995/lc.2023.19235

2023-03-31

Abstract:Recension du livre: Claude Maisonnier. La Chapelle de Ronchamp, naissance d’un chef-d’œuvre. Paris : Éditions du Linteau, 2021. ISBN : 978-2-37497-009-7

English Else
I AND THE LOOK OF THE OTHER: AN EXISTENTIAL CRITIQUE

Ajanwachukwu Edward Okoro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21474/ijar01/17147

2023-06-30

International Journal of Advanced Research

Abstract:Sigmund Freud in one of his most influential books Civilization and its Discontents points out that the individual must face three types of dangers: disease of the body, natural calamities from the external physical environment and the hostility of persons. Through the advanced medical science and the development of modern technology, the first two dangers have lost much of their terror. But dangers from the hostility of other persons have not decreased. The question then becomes: has this danger not decreased because men are yet unsuccessful in finding a way of reducing it or because the nature of man is such that the danger cannot conceivably be reduced? Jean Paul Sartre an existentialist sees the harmonious interpersonal relationships are impossible because of the very nature of the human condition. This work therefore is geared towards expounding the absurdity of inter-subjectivity in the philosophy of this French atheistic existentialist. The main discourse is on the alienation of the self. As to what alienates the self, Sartre would readily say the look of the Other. The discussion therefore centers on how the look of the other influences the self as Sartre conceived it. He had asserted that human communion of any sort is an illusion. The work will expound his attempt to explain love as one of the modes of human relation through a critical existential method.
Presentation of Jean-Marie Souriau's book ''Structure des systèmes dynamiques''

Géry de Saxcé,Charles-Michel Marle

2023-06-04

Abstract:Jean-Marie Souriau's book ''Structure des systèmes dynamiques'', published in 1970, republished recently by Gabay, translated in English and published under the title ''Structure of Dynamical Systems, a Symplectic View of Physic'', is a work with an exceptional wealth which, fifty years after its publication, is still topical. In this paper, we give a rather detailled description of its content and we intend to highlight the ideas that to us, are the most creative and promising.

Dynamical Systems,Mathematical Physics
Lucien Tesnière, Elements of Structural Syntax. Translated by Timothy Osborne and Sylvain Kahane. Amsterdam & Philadelphia, PA: John Benjamins, 2015. Pp. Lxxxii $+$ 698.

Jingyang Jiang,Haitao Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0022226715000249

2015-01-01

Journal of Linguistics

Abstract:An abstract is not available for this content so a preview has been provided. Please use the Get access link above for information on how to access this content.
Literature for All: On Designation and Interpretation in Hugo’s Notre-Dame de Paris

Alexandre Dubois

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/fs/knad030

2023-02-20

French Studies

Abstract:Abstract This article contends that Victor Hugo’s Notre-Dame de Paris is a novel that follows a democratic principle by opening up its meaning, and that of its titular cathedral, to anyone and everyone. Whereas Hugo’s novel and his famous syntagm ‘ceci tuera cela’ have been extensively studied as an examination of the fall of architecture in favour of the printed book, this article will argue that a semiotic analysis of the syntagm reveals Hugo’s intention to recognize the legitimacy of society’s subjects to experience and talk about (artistic) objects. Through a discussion of the chapters added in the book’s second edition and in which Hugo comments on his own work, this article recontextualizes the spatial, historical, and political components that help clarify the democratic intent at the centre of the novel, but also of its resurgence in popularity in 2019 when Notre-Dame was devastated by fire.
Not Merely a Newsworthy Commodity: Jean-Paul Sartre's Engagement in the Struggle Against Apartheid

Tal Sela

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02560046.2019.1691616

2020-01-02

Critical Arts

Abstract:Jean-Paul Sartre's renown and intellectual celebrity grew as a function of his engagement in Third World struggles. Sartre's public image as a champion of the oppressed is so entrenched that it might seem self-evident that he played a leading role in the anti-apartheid struggle. However, his actual contribution to the South African struggle appears to be at odds with the way it is inscribed in collective memory. This article examines the incongruity between Sartre's actual involvement in the struggle against apartheid and his enduring image as a champion of the anti-racist struggle in South Africa. Archival research into Sartre's publications, public appearances and travels in France and abroad notes only three occasions on which Sartre made a direct reference to apartheid—the first in June 1963, the second in October 1964 and the third in November 1966. Tracing Sartre's involvement chronologically, the article seeks to map more precisely the nature of Sartre's contribution, commitment and responsibility to the French anti-apartheid movement, to uncover different facets of Sartre as a celebrity and a public intellectual, and to offer a better understanding of the period following the Algerian War in France with regard to Third World struggles.
Countertexting One Another: Conceptual Poetics, Flarf, And Derridean Countersignature

laurent milesi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3366/count.2015.0018

2015-01-01

Abstract:Using the precedent of Charles Bernstein's spoof on Charles Olson's 'Projective Verse' poetics manifesto as part of a long contextual introduction on issues of literary filiation, influence, and intertextuality, this essay analyses the recent exchanges between conceptualist poetry (Vanessa Place, Kenneth Goldsmith's 'uncreative writing') and 'flarf' (Drew Gardner) in the light of Derrida's twin notions of signature and countersignature. In the process it ties together reading and writing(-as-rereading) in response and co-responsibility in order to theorise the critical notion of 'countertextuality' as a more contemporary inflection of the mechanics of literary interaction known as intertextuality, better suited to characterise the textual interaction between current poetic movements. The critical apparatus and developments in the footnotes are also conceived as a creative enactment of the countertext, whose final instance (the epilogue, or 'Necrologue') is a parodic rewriting performatively exposing the creative impasse and derivativeness of several recent textual productions mimicking Sol LeWitt's 'Sentences on Conceptual Art'. As it moves towards its final critical part, the essay also puts forward, while enacting them, more general views about the relative sterility of some aspects of contemporary poetic debates while gesturing for a possible way out, via Felix Bernstein's 'Notes on Postconceptual Poetry', in order to reclaim 'the genuinely imaginary-affective-intellectual fabric and texture of the poetical'.
B Effects: Bonds of Form and Time in Barthes, Blanchot and Beckett

Laurent Milesi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3366/para.2022.0394

2022-01-01

Paragraph

Abstract:Starting from Nicholas Zurbrugg’s dismissal of the negative ‘B-Effect’ in postmodernism, which he associates with ‘Benjamin, Brecht, Beckett, Barthes, Baudrillard, and Bourdieu’, this essay examines the common rationale behind convergent affirmations of a neutrality or minimalism, often mistaken for nihilism, at key junctures in the works of Samuel Beckett and Roland Barthes, adding Maurice Blanchot as a critical link. The argument unfolds along a double axis: it first considers the formal role of ‘chatter’ or ‘idle speech’ and the fragment(ary in writing) in the three ‘B-writers’ before relating them to different constructions of temporality, such as the ‘future anterior’ and the après-coup, in their thematizations of ‘catastrophe’ and ‘disaster’ as indirect responses to personal or historical trauma and death. A brief concluding paragraph highlights how time’s suspensiveness leads to different forms of waiting across Barthes, Blanchot and Beckett.
SÉANCE TENANTE: Deconstruction in (the) Place of Ethics Now

Laurent Milesi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13534645.2014.988908

2015-01-01

Parallax

Abstract:One of the perceived hallmarks of ‘vintage deconstruction’, ever since Derrida’s trio of monographs in 1967, has been its questioning of origins and of the plenitude of presence, and more recently – since Specters ofMarx grappled with issues of spectrality, messianicity and virtuality – of the contemporary and the ‘now’. Equally prevalent, until Critchley’s timely corrective and Bernasconi’s earlier work on Derrida’s indebtedness to Levinas, had been the impatience with deconstruction’s alleged inability to propose an ethics as well as a politics on grounds that it always defers the criticalmoment of decision-making, whereas both the so-called ethical choice involving responsibility and political action would be deemed to require for maximum efficiency an urgency of response in the here and now, forthwith, séance tenante.
East Asian translations of Jean-Paul Sartre’s pre-1950 literary works

Sabrina Choi Kit Yeung

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/babel.00389.yeu

2024-04-02

Abstract:Abstract Starting from his first appearance in an East-Asian literary magazine and ending with his last works to be translated before the decline of his popularity in Hong Kong and Taiwan during the Cold War, the period 1938–1975 saw extensive translations of Sartre’s literary works in East-Asia (Japan, Mainland China, Taiwan, Hong Kong). This study examines Sartre’s literary works published before 1950, by which most of his renowned ones have been published in France. Divided into Japanese and Chinese sections, it first elaborates on the state of translation of Sartre’s literary works in East Asia from 1938 to 1975 before explaining the phenomenon of multiple translated versions and their differences. The focus then turns to two specific translation cases, one in Japanese and another in Chinese, as examples to illustrate the relation between the vibrant scene of translation attempts within the East Asian region and the wartime situations of the Second World War and the Cold War era. By conducting these investigations, this essay aims to outline how, in Japan, the wartime situation impacted the practice and publication of translations and how, in the case of China, the wartime experience of translators shaped their translation strategies and interpretations regarding Sartre’s literary works.

Deconstructing Sartre

The intelligibility of history (unfinished)/ Jean-Paul Sartre ; edited by Arlette Elkaïm-Sartre ; translated by Quintin Hoare

On "intertextuality" of Sartre's Literary Writings

SARTRE, BOURDIEU, AND GUSTAVE FLAUBERT: FROM INDIVIDUAL FREEDOM AND SOCIAL DETERMINISM IN THE FIELD OF LITERARY CREATION

Nonverbal Communication, Silence and Cultural expressions in Jean-Paul Sartre’s literary Concept: A Philosophical Language and Art View

The Specter of Sartre in Brazilian Concrete Poetry: Paideuma, Affect, Politics, and the Question of World Literature

A truncated manuscript

À propos des Inséparables de Simone de Beauvoir

Questioning Cézanne across Sightlines: Balzac, Zola, and Merleau-Ponty

Sartre Studies in China: from the New Period to the New Century

Françoise Lavocat (a cura di) La théorie littéraire des mondes possibles

Claude Maisonnier. La Chapelle de Ronchamp, naissance d’un chef-d’œuvre

I AND THE LOOK OF THE OTHER: AN EXISTENTIAL CRITIQUE

Presentation of Jean-Marie Souriau's book ''Structure des systèmes dynamiques''

Lucien Tesnière, Elements of Structural Syntax. Translated by Timothy Osborne and Sylvain Kahane. Amsterdam &amp; Philadelphia, PA: John Benjamins, 2015. Pp. Lxxxii $+$ 698.

Literature for All: On Designation and Interpretation in Hugo’s Notre-Dame de Paris

Not Merely a Newsworthy Commodity: Jean-Paul Sartre's Engagement in the Struggle Against Apartheid

Countertexting One Another: Conceptual Poetics, Flarf, And Derridean Countersignature

B Effects: Bonds of Form and Time in Barthes, Blanchot and Beckett

SÉANCE TENANTE: Deconstruction in (the) Place of Ethics Now

East Asian translations of Jean-Paul Sartre’s pre-1950 literary works

Lucien Tesnière, Elements of Structural Syntax. Translated by Timothy Osborne and Sylvain Kahane. Amsterdam & Philadelphia, PA: John Benjamins, 2015. Pp. Lxxxii $+$ 698.