Abstract:The present research investigated whether a target applicant's race and disclosure of their race in a personal diversity statement influenced White evaluators' perceptions of the applicant's egalitarian motivations and their likelihood of contributing to organizational diversity and inclusion outcomes. In Study 1 (N = 206), participants evaluated a diversity statement that was ostensibly written by a White or Black applicant who either referenced or did not reference his race within the statement. Participants judged Black applicants as more internally motivated to be egalitarian and White applicants as more externally motivated, regardless of whether they disclosed their race in the statement. Participants also judged Black applicants as more likely to contribute to diversity and inclusion outcomes than White applicants. Study 2 (N = 257) aimed to replicate Study 1 and tested a strengthened race disclosure condition. We again saw little evidence of race disclosure impacting evaluations of applicants: Black applicants were judged as more internally motivated, less externally motivated, and more likely to contribute to diversity and inclusion compared to White applicants. Study 3 (N = 297) aimed to further replicate and expand on these results by testing a disclosure manipulation wherein the applicant discussed the personal importance/centrality of his race. Once again, applicant race (and not disclosure) demonstrated consistent effects on applicant evaluations. Our results highlight flaws in the personal diversity statement evaluation process, such that factors beyond statement content (i.e., applicant race) influenced perceptions and outcomes of the applicants. Practical implications and solutions for applicant evaluation processes are discussed.

How race influences perceptions of objectivity and hiring preferences

Objectivity interrogation of racial scholarship in psychology and management

Reducing racial bias in scientific communication: Journal policies and their influence on reporting racial demographics.

An Unintentional, Robust, and Replicable Pro-Black Bias in Social Judgment

Potential bias when using social media for selection: Differential effects of candidate demographic characteristics, race match, perceived similarity, and profile detail

Age-based hiring discrimination as a function of equity norms and self-perceived objectivity

Race matters more than racial identity disclosure when evaluating applicant diversity statements

White Attitudes toward Equal Opportunity and Affirmative Action

Judges’ Perceptions of Systemic Racism in the Criminal Justice System

Seeing race and seeming racist? Evaluating strategic colorblindness in social interaction.

The Effects of Editorial-Board Diversity on Race Scholars and Their Scholarship: A Field Experiment

Perceptions of Anti-Black Bias in the Criminal Justice System Contribute to Pro-Black (Versus White) Bias in Criminal Justice Research

On the influence of implicit race attitudes on explicit trustworthiness judgments: An investigation of the perceivers and targets' race and gender intersection

Gender and cultural bias in student evaluations: Why representation matters

Implicit bias and experience influence overall but not relative trustworthiness judgment of other-race faces

Racial Inequality in Psychological Research: Trends of the Past and Recommendations for the Future

What You See Is What You Get? The Impact of Representation Criteria on Human Bias in Hiring

Getting In, Getting Hired, Getting Sideways Looks: Organizational Hierarchy and Perceptions of Racial Discrimination

How racial bias can taint tenure decisions

Does AI Debias Recruitment? Race, Gender, and AI's "Eradication of Difference"

"It's not an overreaction": Increasing White people's acceptance of the reality of bias and receptivity to Black people's bias concerns