Abstract:Cooperation is fundamental for the long-term survival of biological, social, and technological networks. Previously, mechanisms for the enhancement of cooperation, such as network reciprocity, have largely been studied in isolation and with often inconclusive findings. Here, we present an evolutionary, multiagent-based, and spatially explicit computer model to specifically address the interactive interplay between such mechanisms. We systematically investigate the effects of phenotypic diversity, network structure, and rewards on cooperative behavior emerging in a population of reproducing artificial decision makers playing tag-mediated evolutionary games. Cooperative interactions are rewarded such that both the benefits of recipients and costs of donators are affected by the reward size. The reward size is determined by the number of cooperative acts occurring within a given reward time frame. Our computational experiments reveal that small reward frames promote unconditional cooperation in populations with both low and high diversity, whereas large reward frames lead to cycles of conditional and unconditional strategies at high but not at low diversity. Moreover, an interaction between rewards and spatial structure shows that relative to small reward frames, there is a strong difference between the frequency of conditional cooperators populating rewired versus non-rewired networks when the reward frame is large. Notably, in a less diverse population, the total number of defections is comparable across different network topologies, whereas in more diverse environments defections become more frequent in a regularly structured than in a rewired, small-world network of contacts. Acknowledging the importance of such interaction effects in social dilemmas will have inevitable consequences for the future design of cooperation-enhancing protocols in large-scale, distributed, and decentralized systems such as peer-to-peer networks.

Common Organizing Mechanisms in Ecological and Socio-economic Networks

Cooperative Network Dynamics

A Dynamic Niche Model for the Emergence and Evolution of Mutualistic Network Structures

Emergence of structural and dynamical properties of ecological mutualistic networks

Understanding and characterizing nestedness in mutualistic bipartite networks

From Ecology to Finance (and Back?): Recent Advancements in the Analysis of Bipartite Networks

Nestedness in complex networks: Observation, emergence, and implications

Impact of network structure on a model of diffusion and competitive interaction

The role of social attraction and social avoidance in shaping modular networks

An Interaction Switch Predicts the Nested Architecture of Mutualistic Networks

Mesoscale properties of mutualistic networks in ecosystems

Mechanistic interactions as the origin of modularity in biological networks

Breaking the spell of nestedness

Modelling the Network Economy: A Population Ecology Perspective on Network Dynamics

Mutualism provides the basis for biodiversity in eco-evolutionary community assembly

Structural dynamics of plant-pollinator mutualistic networks

How Structured Is the Entangled Bank? The Surprisingly Simple Organization of Multiplex Ecological Networks Leads to Increased Persistence and Resilience

Interspecific competition underlying mutualistic networks

Interspecific competition shapes the structural stability of mutualistic networks

A minimal model for the emergence of cooperation in randomly growing networks

Interplay Between Cooperation-Enhancing Mechanisms in Evolutionary Games with Tag-Mediated Interactions