Abstract:A recently proposed mathematical model of a "core" set of cellular and molecular interactions present in the developing vertebrate limb was shown to exhibit pattern-forming instabilities and limb skeleton-like patterns under certain restrictive conditions, suggesting that it may authentically represent the underlying embryonic process (Hentschel et al., Proc. R. Soc. B 271, 1713-1722, 2004). The model, an eight-equation system of partial differential equations, incorporates the behavior of mesenchymal cells as "reactors," both participating in the generation of morphogen patterns and changing their state and position in response to them. The full system, which has smooth solutions that exist globally in time, is nonetheless highly complex and difficult to handle analytically or numerically. According to a recent classification of developmental mechanisms (Salazar-Ciudad et al., Development 130, 2027-2037, 2003), the limb model of Hentschel et al. is "morphodynamic," since differentiation of new cell types occurs simultaneously with cell rearrangement. This contrasts with "morphostatic" mechanisms, in which cell identity becomes established independently of cell rearrangement. Under the hypothesis that development of some vertebrate limbs employs the core mechanism in a morphostatic fashion, we derive in an analytically rigorous fashion a pair of equations representing the spatiotemporal evolution of the morphogen fields under the assumption that cell differentiation relaxes faster than the evolution of the overall cell density (i.e., the morphostatic limit of the full system). This simple reaction-diffusion system is unique in having been derived analytically from a substantially more complex system involving multiple morphogens, extracellular matrix deposition, haptotaxis, and cell translocation. We identify regions in the parameter space of the reduced system where Turing-type pattern formation is possible, which we refer to as its "Turing space." Obtained values of the parameters are used in numerical simulations of the reduced system, using a new Galerkin finite element method, in tissue domains with nonstandard geometry. The reduced system exhibits patterns of spots and stripes like those seen in developing limbs, indicating its potential utility in hybrid continuum-discrete stochastic modeling of limb development. Lastly, we discuss the possible role in limb evolution of selection for increasingly morphostatic developmental mechanisms.

Waves, patterns, bifurcations: A tutorial review on the vertebrate segmentation clock

Waves, patterns and bifurcations: a tutorial review on the vertebrate segmentation clock

Delayed coupling theory of vertebrate segmentation

Species-specific roles of the Notch ligands, receptors, and targets orchestrating the signaling landscape of the segmentation clock

An analysis of overall network architecture reveals an infinite-period bifurcation underlying oscillation arrest in the segmentation clock

Cell-autonomous timing drives the vertebrate segmentation clock's wave pattern

Modularity of the segmentation clock and morphogenesis

Sequential pattern formation governed by signaling gradients

A Clock and Wavefront Self-Organizing Model Recreates the Dynamics of Mouse Somitogenesis in-vivo and in-vitro

Modelling Coupled Oscillations in the Notch, Wnt, and FGF Signaling Pathways During Somitogenesis: A Comprehensive Mathematical Model

Morphogen-regulated contact-mediated signaling between cells can drive the transitions underlying body segmentation in vertebrates

Foci, waves, excitability : self-organization of phase waves in a model of asymmetrically coupled embryonic oscillators

Spatiotemporal control of pattern formation during somitogenesis

Intercellular Coupling Regulates the Period of the Segmentation Clock

A Β-Catenin Gradient Links the Clock and Wavefront Systems in Mouse Embryo Segmentation

Converting genetic network oscillations into somite spatial pattern

Intrinsic noise, Delta-Notch signalling and delayed reactions promote sustained, coherent, synchronised oscillations in the presomitic mesoderm

Keeping development on time: Insights into post‐transcriptional mechanisms driving oscillatory gene expression during vertebrate segmentation

Controlling human organoid symmetry breaking reveals signaling gradients drive segmentation clock waves

A Complex Oscillating Network of Signaling Genes Underlies the Mouse Segmentation Clock

The morphostatic limit for a model of skeletal pattern formation in the vertebrate limb