Abstract:Background: Health promotion programs can only lead to improvements in health outcomes if they are effectively implemented. However, most studies assessing implementation success focus on only one condition, although more conditions influence this process. Therefore, evidence is scarce on what conditions play a role in successful implementation and how they interact. Hence, we aimed to identify which combinations of teacher and implementation process characteristics affected the emotional and social school experience (SCE) of pupils participating in a school-based health promotion program. Methods: This study was part of an effectiveness and process evaluation including 24 intervention and 27 control classes. We used fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) to identify combinations of conditions that were associated with either an increase or no increase in the outcome SCE in comparison to the control group at 20 months post intervention. We deductively selected five conditions based on the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research: teachers' perceived self-efficacy, teachers' expectations of the benefits of the intervention, teachers' previous knowledge about the intervention, dosage of physical activity breaks, and quality of the implementation. Results: We identified five different pathways that led to no increase in the pupils' outcome (parameters of fit: consistency 94%, coverage 66%). The combination of an unsatisfying quality of implementing the intervention and a low previous knowledge about the intervention showed the highest empirical relevance. Similarly, fewer physical activity breaks in combination with other conditions impeded the program's success. Furthermore, we identified two different pathways characterizing ways to success (consistency: 81%, coverage: 52%). The most relevant combination was good quality implementation of physical activity breaks, implemented by teachers with a high self-efficacy, and a good previous knowledge about the intervention. Conclusions: QCA has potential for an in-depth analysis of complex interventions as it can rely on small to medium sample sizes and analyze pathways to success and non-success separately. The investigated program can be improved by considering the following suggestions: The quality of the implementation process should be monitored during the implementation phase, and regular feedback loops and learning opportunities for teachers should accompany a program. Clear recommendations regarding the dosage should be established. Trial registration: German register of clinical studies: DRKS00000622 . Retrospectively registered: December 3, 2010, ( http://www.drks.de/drks_web/setLocale_EN.do ). Approved by the Ethics Committee of Lower Austria (GS4-EK-4/107-2010).

Supporting underrepresented students in health sciences: a fuzzy cognitive mapping approach to program evaluation

Supporting students from underrepresented minority backgrounds in graduate school: A mixed-methods formative study to inform post-baccalaureate design

Quantitative Evaluation of the Community Research Fellows Training Program

Promoting a Sense of Belonging Among Underrepresented Medical Students Through Cross-Cultural Programming

Evaluating a National Biomedical Training Program Using QuantCrit: Revealing Disparities in Research Self-efficacy for Women of Color Undergraduates

A Feasibility Study Describing the Successes and Challenges of Implementing a Virtual Community Health Worker Training Among High School Students Participating in a Summer STEM Enrichment Program

Affirming and Nurturing Students’ Cultural Wealth to Enhance Self-efficacy: Examination of Urban High School Students’ Lived Experiences in a STEM-Medicine Pipeline Program

Addressing Workforce Disparities by Improving the Academic Resilience and Professionalism of Health Science Students Through Structured and Targeted Supports

Summer of Translational Aging Research for Undergraduates (STAR U): Short-term outcomes of a training program to advance diversity in aging research

A model of mentorship for students from historically underrepresented groups in STEM

Stepping Up Summer Fun: the Cancer Research – Scholarship and Training Experience in Population Sciences (C-STEPS) Program

Barriers and opportunities for promoting health professions careers among African American students in the Midwest

Fine-Tuning Summer Research Programs to Promote Underrepresented Students' Persistence in the STEM Pathway

Project Strengthen: An STEMM-focused career development workshop to prepare underrepresented minority students for graduate school

Implementing and Evaluating Manualized Interventions in U.S. Organizations Serving Youth with Foster Care Experience: Lessons Learned from the Field

Pathways leading to success and non-success: a process evaluation of a cluster randomized physical activity health promotion program applying fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis

The Implementation of Farm-to-University Program in Historically Black Colleges and Universities: Assessment of Feasibility and Barriers

Development of the "Through the Eyes of …" Program for Improving Cultural Awareness

University Mental Health Outreach Targeting Students of Color

Area Health Education Center (AHEC) programs for rural and underrepresented minority students in the Alabama Black Belt

Supporting healthcare professionals from ethnic minority backgrounds to 'Step Into' a clinical academic career