Reducing Barriers and Improving Motivations of Students Enrolled in SHPEPs
Leila Amiri,Will Ross
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.52426
2024-01-27
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:The persistence of health inequalities in the United States, which have been extensively studied since the 1985 Heckler Report, 1 has resulted in an unconscionable, preventable loss of lives. The Heckler Report and other studies compelled former US Secretary of Health and Human Services, Louis W. Sullivan, to establish the Sullivan Commission 2 in 2003, which made policy recommendations to bring about systemic change that addressed the scarcity of racial and ethnic minority individuals in the health professions. Dr Sullivan commented on "missing persons," the diverse health care workforce who could work collaboratively to ameliorate health disparities. A growing body of evidence 3 links the societal benefit of increased racial and ethnic diversity among health care professionals to the enhanced delivery of culturally appropriate care to a diverse patient population. However, health care practitioners from minoritized races and ethnicities are largely underrepresented in the health care workforce. 4 Less than 12% of US physicians identify as either Hispanic or Black, although according to the US Census, the percentages of these groups in the US population are 18.3% and 13.4%, respectively 5 ,6 Similarly, the collective percentage of Hispanic and Black pharmacists at 17.5% and dentists at 14.7% 7 in the United States is lower than their representation in the population. Pathway programs supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration under titles VII and VIII of the Public Health Service Act, as well as other federal programs, are ideal opportunities to promote a racially and ethnically diverse workforce that will enhance patient care and ensure health equity. One of the pathway programs, the Summer Health Professions Exposure Program (SHPEP), directed by a team of investigators at the University of Florida, has nurtured the next generation of diverse health care professionals who will help usher in a "culture of health." The "culture of health" concept is based on the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation's vision of "enabling all to live longer, healthier lives now and for future generations." 8 One of the expressed goals of SHPEPs is to reduce negative stereotypes around academic ability, professional competency, and interpersonal ability among students. While SHPEPs have produced an impressive number of future health professionals, with 73.7% scholars from underrepresented backgrounds in 2023, there is limited data on outcomes associated with reduced negative stereotypes, particularly on the degree of self-efficacy, or changes in students' motivations and barriers to entering health professional schools. Xirau-Probert and colleagues 9 conducted a retrospective, single-center study at the University of Florida, analyzing 5 years of SHPEP Career Barrier Survey data to ascertain whether there were any changes to motivations or barriers in students in the SHPEP. Survey responses indicated a positive impact on participants and their perceptions of barriers to entering health professions schools. Notably, some participants completed the program virtually, and there was no difference in their positive perceptions of motivators after completion of the program. Furthermore, while the virtual participants wanted in-person experiences, their survey responses indicated a positive outcome as well. This program, in its various modes of delivery, is one example of a successful effort to support the systemic change necessary to increase minority representative in heath careers. The June 2023 ruling of the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) on race conscious admissions has created general concern for the future diversity of the US health care workforce, 10 as state bans and prior SCOTUS decisions have been shown to reduce the diversity of enrolled classes. This is particularly problematic as we rely on programs like the SHPEP to increase the diversity of our workforce. In an environment where race cannot be taken into consideration, admissions processes need to be reimagined to ensure racially and ethnically aligned care for our patients. The admissions community, the gatekeepers of health professions education, is now faced with a major legal change that offers opportunities to revisit admissions and holistic review processes. This reimagination can begin with ensuring that the mission of each institution is clear on the goal of diversity for the student body as an urgent public health need. Once the mission is set, health professions programs need to develop creative ways of supporting historically marginalized learners on their journey to the health professions. Ideally, the support should be a continuum that begins in middle school and continues in high school and college, with experiences such as the SHPEP as a bridge between kindergarten to 12th grade ( -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal