HBCUs Are an Undervalued Resource for Addressing the US Physician Shortage
Mytien Nguyen,Erica H. Sutton,Hyacinth R. C. Mason
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.40966
2024-10-25
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:Weiss and colleagues' timely study 1 examining the perspective of premedical advisers from historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) on medical school admission among Black students is critically important to inform medical school admissions practices after the recent US Supreme Court decision on race-neutral admissions. 2 Interviewing 26 premedical advisers from HBCUs, the authors found 3 emerging themes: (1) variation in relationships with medical schools, with some premedical advisers characterizing relationships with predominantly White allopathic medical schools as exploitative and relationships with osteopathic, Caribbean, and HBCU medical schools as supportive; (2) significant disparity in premedical resource allocation (eg, shadowing opportunities for HBCU undergraduates); and (3) the importance of incorporating family, peers, and alumni in helping Black premedical students navigate the physician pathway. 1 As the US faces a significant deficit in producing a physician workforce that meets the needs of the diverse population, 3 HBCUs have and continue to be important contributors to helping ensure a diverse physician workforce. Established in the 1800s, HBCUs have extended college access to Black students for centuries. Although HBCUs make up only 3% of US colleges and universities, they produce 20% of all Black college graduates and 25% of Black science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) graduates. 4 Some HBCUs, like Xavier University of Louisiana in New Orleans, produce more Black students who apply to medical school than most, often larger, and more well-resourced predominantly White institutions (PWIs) across the US. Historically, HBCUs have successfully done so by approaching premedical education and advising holistically, creating collaborative STEM coursework, engaging family early, and providing premedical advising and skills-building starting with the first year of college. 3 Data show that HBCUs provide a fostering, identity-affirming, culturally inclusive educational environment for Black students. 5 Compared with Black graduates from non-HBCU colleges, Black graduates from HBCUs are more likely to report social, emotional, and financial well-being. 5 Despite this, there has been a marked decline in medical school graduates from HBCUs in recent years. Between 2004 and 2018, the number of Black MD HBCU graduates dropped from 278 to 143, with a corresponding decrease in the proportion of Black graduates coming from HBCUs from 26.2% to 9.8%. 6 Weiss and colleagues' study 1 sheds light on the holistic, student-centered approach that HBCU premedical advisers described that they used in supporting students. Given that even after entering medical school, Black students are more likely than their peers to leave medical training, 7 ,8 it is critical for medical schools to not only holistically admit students from diverse backgrounds but also provide the holistic student support needed to ensure that all students thrive. 9 Premedical school advisers described applying holistic advising approaches, such as a prehealth induction ceremony to incorporate family members in the premedical education process. Medical schools, especially PWI allopathic medical schools, should partner with HBCU premedical advisers and incorporate more holistic and targeted premedical student approaches that contribute to educational equity, lead to a continuity of support from the premedical phase through undergraduate medical education and beyond, and promote a thriving environment for all trainees. Partnerships are not enough. Compared with peer institutions, HBCUs have historically been severely underfunded. The long-lasting impact with the marginalization of HBCUs in premedical education was well characterized by HBCU premedical advisers who were interviewed by Weiss and colleagues. 1 While studies have found that HBCUs with strong medical school affiliations and externally sponsored enrichment programs are more successful in gaining admission to medical schools for their students than those without such affiliations and programs, 10 HBCU premedical advisers in the current study shared that they were challenged to find the critical clinical opportunities that students needed to be successful medical school applicants. They cited competition with more resourced and connected local and regional PWIs as a particular obstacle. In the setting of this scarcity, relationships with predominantly White medical schools could serve as a bridge for HBCU premedical students. However, advisers characterized that while predominantly White medical schools offered outreach to HBCU students, they did not holistically consider HBCU students for admissions. Therefore, HBCU premedical students may be doubly disadvantaged -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal