Abstract:As the Wall Street Journal recently put it, “America has a rap sheet.” Today, between 70 and 100 million people in the United States have a criminal arrest or conviction record, and anyone — including employers, landlords, and data collection companies — can easily access these records on line. At the same time, collateral consequences of even the most minor offenses have increased exponentially, affecting employment, housing, parenting, and just about every other aspect of daily life. The convergence of mass criminalization, ubiquitous criminal records, and pervasive collateral consequences is a major factor in the criminal justice system’s troubling racial and economic disparities. States are reacting to the criminal records crisis in different ways, with many focusing on expanding record sealing or expungement laws that currently range widely in the relief offered. The time has come for a well-tailored response to mass criminalization and collateral consequences in the information age. Sealing and expungement laws must be part of a multi-faceted approach to alleviating harmful consequences of a criminal record. The goal of limiting access to and use of relevant criminal records to those with a legitimate need to know is best advanced through focused legislative reform. This Article describes why well-crafted sealing and expungement laws matter, responds to the major moral and practical arguments against such laws, and situates sealing and expungement as part of a comprehensive scheme for relief from a criminal record. Reforms might include regulating data brokers to ensure that sealed or expunged records are removed from their databases, banning employers from asking about arrests not ending in conviction or expunged convictions in the absence of a statutory mandate to do so, and offering employers who comply with such rules immunity from certain negligent hiring lawsuits.

Free to Work: Measuring Workforce Outcomes After Illinois' Criminal Records Reforms

Making Ends Meet: An Examination of Legal and Illegal Sources of Financial Support for Individuals Returning from Prison

Expunging America's Rap Sheet in the Information Age

Reflections on Criminal Justice Reform: Challenges and Opportunities

From prison to work? Job-crime patterns for women in a precarious labor market

Certifiably employable? Occupational regulation and unemployment duration

Amnesty Policy and Elite Persistence in the Postbellum South: Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity Design

Ghosting the Machine: Judicial Resistance to a Recidivism Risk Assessment Instrument

Journey Out of Neverland: CORI Reform, Commonwealth v. Peter Pon, and Massachusetts’s Emergence as a National Exemplar for Criminal Record Sealing

Protecting Postville? The impact of deportation and immigration on crime

Power to the Paperwork? Mandatory Financial Sanctions and the Bureaucratic Means to Racially Unequal Ends

Where Did All the White Criminals Go?: Reconfiguring Race and Crime on the Road to Mass Incarceration

Rethinking the Benefits of Youth Employment Programs: The Heterogeneous Effects of Summer Jobs

Criminal Employment Law

An Examination of Prison-Based Programming and Prison Misconduct

An Empirical Evaluation of the Impact of New York's Bail Reform on Crime Using Synthetic Controls

Wheeling into School and Out of Crime: Evidence from Linking Driving Licenses to Minimum Academic Requirements

Financial Literacy Education in a Work Release Program for an Incarcerated Sample

Courts, Crime and Economic Performance: Evidence from a Judicial Reform in Kenya

Thinking, Fast and Slow? Some Field Experiments to Reduce Crime and Dropout in Chicago

Evaluating Firearm Violence After New Jersey's Cash Bail Reform