Abstract:A historic debate in biology is the question of nature vs. nurture. Although it is now known that most traits are a product of both heredity ("nature") and the environment ("nurture"), these two driving forces of trait development are rarely examined together. In birds, one important aspect of the early developmental environment is egg incubation temperature. Small changes (<1°C) in incubation temperature can have large effects on a wide-array of offspring traits. One important trait is metabolism, because it is related to life-history traits and strategies, organismal performance, and energetic and behavioral strategies. Although it has been shown that embryonic and post-hatch metabolism are related to egg incubation temperature, little is known about how this may vary as a function of genetic differences or post-hatching environmental conditions. Here, we investigated this question in zebra finches ( Taeniopygia guttata ). We experimentally incubated eggs at two different temperatures: 37.5°C (control), which is optimal for this species and 36.3°C (low), which is suboptimal. We first measured embryonic heart rate as a proxy of embryonic metabolic rate. Then, at hatch, we cross-fostered nestlings to differentiate genetic and pre-hatching factors from post-hatching environmental conditions. When offspring were 30 days-old, we measured their resting metabolic rate (RMR; within the thermoneutral zone) and thermoregulatory metabolic rate (TMR; 12°C; birds must actively thermoregulate). We also measured RMR and TMR of all genetic and foster parents. We found that embryonic heart rate was greater in eggs incubated at the control temperature than those at the low temperature. Further, embryonic heart rate was positively related to genetic father RMR, suggesting that it is both heritable and affected by the pre-natal environment. In addition, we found that post-hatch metabolic rates were positively related to genetic parent metabolic rate, and interactively related to incubation temperature and foster mother metabolic rate. Altogether, this suggests that metabolism and the energetic cost of thermoregulation can be influenced by genetics, the pre-natal environment, and the post-natal environment. Our study sheds light on how environmental changes and parental care may affect avian physiology, as well as which traits may be susceptible to natural selection.

Early-life environmental effects on birds: epigenetics and microbiome as mechanisms underlying long-lasting phenotypic changes

Early experiences matter: a review of the effects of prenatal environment on offspring characteristics in poultry

The effects of early-life ambient temperature on the gut microbiome of a wild bird? an experimental approach

Early developmental carry‐over effects on exploratory behaviour and DNA methylation in wild great tits (Parus major)

Variation in DNA methylation in avian nestlings is largely determined by genetic effects

Dynamics of Gut Microbiota Diversity During the Early Development of an Avian Host: Evidence From a Cross-Foster Experiment

Timing matters: age-dependent impacts of the social environment and host selection on the avian gut microbiota

Early environment influences later performance in fishes

Transgenerational transmission of maternal stimulatory experience in domesticated birds.

Individual variation in the avian gut microbiota: the influence of host state and environmental heterogeneity

Variation in the thermal plasticity of avian embryos is produced by the developmental environment, not genes

Nature vs. Nurture: Disentangling the Influence of Inheritance, Incubation Temperature, and Post-Natal Care on Offspring Heart Rate and Metabolism in Zebra Finches

Indirect maternal effects via nest microbiome composition drive gut colonization in altricial chicks

The impact of parental and developmental stress on DNA methylation in the avian hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis

Maternally derived avian corticosterone affects offspring genome‐wide DNA methylation in a passerine species

Effects of the temperature during embryonic development on adult reproduction and the phenotype of the second generation in zebra finches

Sublethal effects of early-life exposure to common and emerging contaminants in birds

Epigenetics and the environment: emerging patterns and implications

Gut microbiome and telomere length in gull hatchlings

Embryonic manipulations shape life-long, heritable stress responses through complex epigenetic mechanisms: a review

Early-life environmental effects on mitochondrial aerobic metabolism: a brood size manipulation in wild great tits