Abstract:A historic debate in biology is the question of nature vs. nurture. Although it is now known that most traits are a product of both heredity ("nature") and the environment ("nurture"), these two driving forces of trait development are rarely examined together. In birds, one important aspect of the early developmental environment is egg incubation temperature. Small changes (<1°C) in incubation temperature can have large effects on a wide-array of offspring traits. One important trait is metabolism, because it is related to life-history traits and strategies, organismal performance, and energetic and behavioral strategies. Although it has been shown that embryonic and post-hatch metabolism are related to egg incubation temperature, little is known about how this may vary as a function of genetic differences or post-hatching environmental conditions. Here, we investigated this question in zebra finches ( Taeniopygia guttata ). We experimentally incubated eggs at two different temperatures: 37.5°C (control), which is optimal for this species and 36.3°C (low), which is suboptimal. We first measured embryonic heart rate as a proxy of embryonic metabolic rate. Then, at hatch, we cross-fostered nestlings to differentiate genetic and pre-hatching factors from post-hatching environmental conditions. When offspring were 30 days-old, we measured their resting metabolic rate (RMR; within the thermoneutral zone) and thermoregulatory metabolic rate (TMR; 12°C; birds must actively thermoregulate). We also measured RMR and TMR of all genetic and foster parents. We found that embryonic heart rate was greater in eggs incubated at the control temperature than those at the low temperature. Further, embryonic heart rate was positively related to genetic father RMR, suggesting that it is both heritable and affected by the pre-natal environment. In addition, we found that post-hatch metabolic rates were positively related to genetic parent metabolic rate, and interactively related to incubation temperature and foster mother metabolic rate. Altogether, this suggests that metabolism and the energetic cost of thermoregulation can be influenced by genetics, the pre-natal environment, and the post-natal environment. Our study sheds light on how environmental changes and parental care may affect avian physiology, as well as which traits may be susceptible to natural selection.

Variation in the thermal plasticity of avian embryos is produced by the developmental environment, not genes

The incubation environment does not explain significant variation in heart rate plasticity among avian embryos

Variation in Embryonic Metabolic Reaction Norms and the Role of the Environment

Adaptive responses of the embryos of birds and reptiles to spatial and temporal variations in nest temperatures.

The Behavioural and Physiological Strategies of Bird and Reptile Embryos in Response to Unpredictable Variation in Nest Temperature.

Heat‐induced maternal effects shape avian eggshell traits and embryo development and phenotype at high incubation temperatures

Nature vs. Nurture: Disentangling the Influence of Inheritance, Incubation Temperature, and Post-Natal Care on Offspring Heart Rate and Metabolism in Zebra Finches

Within the optimal thermal range, temperature fluctuations with similar means have little effect on offspring phenotypes: A comparison of two approaches that simulate natural nest conditions

Separating the genetic and environmental drivers of body temperature during the development of endothermy in an altricial bird

Warm and thermally variable incubation conditions reduce embryonic performance and carry over to influence hatchling tradeoffs

Impact of developmental temperatures on thermal plasticity and repeatability of metabolic rate

Within population plastic responses to combined thermal-nutritional stress differ from those in response to single stressors, and are genetically independent across traits in both males and females

Parental Effects and Climate Change: Will Avian Incubation Behavior Shield Embryos from Increasing Environmental Temperatures?

High atmospheric temperatures and ‘ambient incubation’ drive embryonic development and lead to earlier hatching in a passerine bird

Effects of the temperature during embryonic development on adult reproduction and the phenotype of the second generation in zebra finches

Incubation Temperature and Maternal Resource Provisioning, but Not Contaminant Exposure, Shape Hatchling Phenotypes in a Species with Temperature-Dependent Sex Determination

Context dependence of transgenerational plasticity: the influence of parental temperature depends on offspring environment and sex

Prehatching temperatures drive inter-annual cohort differences in great tit metabolism

Embryonic Temperature Programs Phenotype in Reptiles

Maternal Thermal Environment Induces Plastic Responses in the Reproductive Life History of Oviparous Lizards.

Thermal Manipulation During Embryogenesis Impacts H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 Histone Marks in Chicken Hypothalamus