Vascularized Tissue to Reduce Fistula After Salvage Total Laryngectomy: A Network Meta‐analysis
Andrew Williamson,Faizan Shah,Irene Benaran,Vinidh Paleri
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/lary.31287
IF: 2.97
2024-01-19
The Laryngoscope
Abstract:We have performed an update of a systematic review first published in 2014 which found a rate of pharyngocutaneous fistula (PCF) after salvage laryngectomy using primary closure of 31.2% and 22.2% with flap‐assisted closure, and a number needed to treat of 11. This updated review found an increase in the rate of PCF after primary closure of 37% and further reduction following flap‐assisted closure to 19%, with a resultant reduction in the number needed to treat of 6.5. In addition, the PCF rates after free, pedicled, on‐lay, and patch flaps were 17% (OR 0.62), 16% (OR 0.36), 15% (OR 0.38), and 16% (OR 0.39), respectively. Additional network meta‐analysis found that all combinations of free and pedicled flaps using reinforcement and patch closure methods were superior to primary closure techniques. Objective Salvage laryngectomy is more predisposed to complications than primary operations, with pharyngocutaneous fistula (PCF) being among the most challenging to manage. Vascularized flaps are increasingly employed during salvage laryngectomy, with a previous review finding a PCF incidence of 31.2% and 22.2% after primary and flap‐assisted closure respectively. We aim to better define the role of vascularized flaps after salvage laryngectomy by performing an updated review comparing the rate of PCF in those undergoing primary or vascularized flap‐assisted closure. Data Sources Pubmed/Medline, CINAHL, and CENTRAL. Review Methods An updated literature review was conducted of English language literature from 2003 to 2023. A random effects and network meta‐analysis of odds ratios (OR) and pooled proportions were conducted. Results Literature search found 31 studies, including seven from the previous review. Overall random effects pooled PCF rate was 25% (95% CI 0.21; 0.30, I2 = 72%, p = <0.01), whereas incidence in primary closure was 37% (95% CI 0.32; 0.43, I2 = 60%, p = <0.01) and 19% (95% CI 0.12; 0.20, I2 = 47%, p = <0.01) after flap closure. Pooled OR was 0.39 (95% CI 0.28; 0.55, I2 = 36%, p = 0.04) in favor of vascularized tissues. The number needed to treat was 6.5. The rate of PCF was lower after free and pedicled flaps, and on‐lay and patch closure compared to primary closure techniques. Network meta‐analysis found all combinations of closure techniques and vascularized tissue were superior to primary closure. Conclusion The updated analysis has demonstrated a widening in the rates of PCF between primary and vascularized flap‐assisted closure. Surgeons should strongly consider the use of free or pedicled flaps in any salvage laryngectomy procedure. Laryngoscope, 2024
medicine, research & experimental,otorhinolaryngology