Art therapy masks reflect emotional changes in military personnel with PTSS

V. Estrada Gonzalez,V. Meletaki,M. Walker,J. Payano Sosa,A. Stamper,R. Srikanchana,J. L. King,K. Scott,E. R. Cardillo,C. Sours Rhodes,A. P. Christensen,K. M. Darda,C. I. Workman,A. Chatterjee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-57128-5

IF: 4.6

2024-03-28

Scientific Reports

Abstract:Among disabling post-traumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) are irritability, aggressive behavior, distressing memories and general impaired cognition and negative mood. Art therapy interventions, including mask-making, can potentially alleviate these symptoms. We tested the hypothesis that art conveys emotions and predicted that blinded viewers would be able to perceive changes in theoretically derived emotional profiles expressed in art made by military personnel with PTSS from the onset to the end of therapy. Five service members and veterans exhibiting PTSS were enrolled in an 8-session art therapy protocol, during which they artistically transformed papier-mâché masks at the beginning and end of the protocol. We found that blinded viewers without knowledge of the masks' creation stage (onset or end of therapy) read initial masks as conveying more negative emotions (e.g., angry, upset, and challenged) and later masks as conveying more positive emotions (calm and pleasure). Based on the assessments from the blinded evaluators, we infer the emotional transition experienced by the participants was expressed in the masks. In an exploratory arm of the study, we also found that viewers were better able to empathize with the negative emotions experienced by participants with PTSS when asked to explicitly take their perspective.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore whether art therapy can convey emotional changes through artworks and to verify whether blind reviewers can perceive these emotional changes from the masks created by military personnel before and after treatment for post-traumatic stress symptoms (PTSS).

#### Background and Motivation
1. **Symptoms of PTSS**: PTSS patients often exhibit symptoms such as irritability, aggressive behavior, distressing memories, and impaired cognition and emotions.
2. **Role of Art Therapy**: Art therapy, especially mask-making, is believed to alleviate these symptoms. Art, as a non-verbal form of expression, can help patients externalize and process complex emotions and memories.
3. **Research Hypothesis**: The research hypothesizes that artworks can convey emotions and predicts that blind reviewers can perceive the emotional changes in the artworks created by military personnel before and after treatment.

#### Research Methods
1. **Participants**: Five active-duty and veteran military personnel with PTSS participated in an 8-session art therapy protocol.
2. **Experimental Design**: Participants created papier-mâché masks at the beginning and end of the treatment. These masks were presented to a group of independent observers who were unaware of the stage of treatment during which the masks were made.
3. **Assessment Metrics**: Observers filled out questionnaires to evaluate the cognitive and emotional impact elicited by the masks.

#### Main Findings
1. **Emotional Changes**: Blind reviewers perceived that the masks from the initial stage expressed more negative emotions (such as anger, unease, and challenge), while the masks from the later stage expressed more positive emotions (such as calmness and pleasure).
2. **Emotional Regulation**: These observations support the research hypothesis that art-making can express emotional changes and reflect the positive impact of treatment on the emotions of PTSS patients.
3. **Perspective Orientation**: The study also found that when observers were guided to consider the emotional state of the artist, their evaluations of the masks were more positive, especially in terms of aesthetics and interest.

#### Conclusion
1. **Effectiveness of Art Therapy**: Art therapy, particularly mask-making, can be an effective means for PTSS patients to express and regulate emotions.
2. **Visualization of Emotional Changes**: Through artworks, the internal emotional changes of patients can be perceived by external observers, providing a new method for assessing treatment outcomes.
3. **Impact of Perspective Orientation**: Guiding observers to consider the emotional state of the artist can enhance their appreciation and understanding of the artworks, thereby improving the effectiveness of the therapy.

In summary, this paper empirically validates the effectiveness of art therapy in PTSS treatment and provides new perspectives for understanding and assessing the emotional changes of patients.