Effectiveness of trauma-focused art therapy (TFAT) for psychological trauma: study protocol of a multiple-baseline single-case experimental design

Jackie Heijman,Hans Wouters,Karin Alice Schouten,Suzanne Haeyen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-081917
IF: 3.006
2024-01-30
BMJ Open
Abstract:Introduction Treatments such as eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing and (narrative) exposure therapies are commonly used in psychological trauma. In everyday practice, art therapy is also often used, although rigorous research on its efficacy is lacking. Patients seem to benefit from the indirect, non-verbal experiential approach of art therapy. This protocol paper describes a study to examine the effectiveness of a 10-week individual trauma-focused art therapy (TFAT) intervention. Methods and analysis A mixed-methods multiple-baseline single-case experimental design will be conducted with 25–30 participants with psychological trauma. Participants will be randomly assigned to a baseline period lasting 3–5 weeks, followed by the TFAT intervention (10 weeks) and follow-up (3 weeks). Quantitative measures will be completed weekly: the Beck Depression Inventory-II, the Mental Health Continuum Short Form, the Resilience Scale, the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale and the Self-expression and Emotion Regulation in Art Therapy Scale. The Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Checklist-5 will be completed at week 1 and week 10. Qualitative instruments comprise a semistructured interview with each individual patient and therapist, and a short evaluation for the referrer. Artwork will be used to illustrate the narrative findings. Quantitative outcomes will be analysed with linear mixed models using the MultiSCED web application. Qualitative analyses will be performed using thematic analysis with ATLAS.ti. Ethics and dissemination This study has been approved by the ethics committee of the HAN University of Applied Sciences (ECO 394.0922). All participants will sign an informed consent form and data will be treated confidentially. Findings will be published open access in peer-reviewed journals. Trial registration number NCT05593302.
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is the evaluation of the effectiveness and functionality of Trauma-Focused Art Therapy (TFAT) in treating psychological trauma. Specifically, the main research question is: - **Can TFAT interventions improve patients' self-expression and emotional regulation abilities in art therapy, and reduce trauma-related symptoms (including direct trauma symptoms, depressive symptoms, and declines in well-being, self-esteem, and resilience)?** The secondary research question is: - **How do patients, therapists, and clinicians perceive the effects of TFAT interventions?** ### Background and Motivation According to the Dutch guidelines for the treatment of psychological trauma and stress-related disorders, many "experience experts" (i.e., individuals who have experienced trauma) hold a positive attitude towards Art Therapy (AT), considering it particularly valuable when patients find it difficult to express their traumatic experiences verbally. However, there is currently a lack of rigorous scientific research to prove the effectiveness of AT. Additionally, traditional Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET), and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) are widely recommended for treating PTSD, but more than one-third of patients do not benefit from these treatments, especially those with severe trauma, poor verbal memory, or difficulty discussing their traumatic experiences. ### Research Objectives This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of TFAT interventions through a mixed-methods design (combining quantitative and qualitative methods). The ultimate goal is to improve the quality and accessibility of trauma treatment for patients who respond poorly to traditional talk therapies. If TFAT is proven effective, this intervention will be promoted and implemented to provide appropriate treatment, avoiding situations where these patients remain untreated or receive long-term ineffective treatment. ### Hypotheses The researchers hypothesize that TFAT interventions are effective in treating trauma-related symptoms, specifically including: 1. **Enhancing self-expression and emotional regulation abilities** 2. **Reducing trauma symptoms** 3. **Reducing depressive symptoms** 4. **Enhancing self-confidence/self-esteem** 5. **Enhancing psychological resilience** To ensure the objectivity of the qualitative analysis, the research team did not make any assumptions about the perceptions of patients, therapists, and clinicians regarding TFAT.