Power market reform in China: Motivations, progress, and recommendations

Hongye Guo,Michael R. Davidson,Qixin Chen,Da Zhang,Nan Jiang,Qing Xia,Chongqing Kang,Xiliang Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2020.111717

IF: 9

2020-10-01

Energy Policy

Abstract:<p>China's electricity demand has grown rapidly over only two decades and is currently the largest in the world. This was largely owing to a framework of regulation in which governments regulated prices and quantities, and there was ample incentive for investment. As the growth in electricity demand has slowed and the use of renewable energy has been impeded by integration-related challenges, China has embarked on a new round of power sector reform, with a focus on market construction. Considering four years of market experiments at the provincial level, we review the backgrounds and goals of the reforms, as well as the current progress toward meeting the initial targets. Then, we discuss the key challenges to be overcome to achieve complete implementation of the reforms, with special emphasis on the system of dispatch. We recommend that China's reforms, in order to achieve the goal of market-based competition, must embrace short-term markets, a greater role for independent regulation, compatibility with renewable energy, and inter-provincial coordination.</p>

economics,environmental studies,energy & fuels,environmental sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address several key issues in the reform of China's electricity market, mainly including:

1. **Improving the Efficiency of Power Generation Assets**:
- Over the past decade, China's installed power generation capacity has grown at an average annual rate of 9.2%, but demand growth has not kept pace, leading to a significant decline in the utilization rate of power generation equipment. For example, between 2011 and 2016, the annual utilization hours of thermal power equipment dropped from 57.9% to 46.6%. This is mainly due to the imperfect investment approval mechanism and electricity pricing rules under the traditional electricity sales mechanism, which prevent local governments from making informed decisions, resulting in over-investment and low efficiency of power generation assets.

2. **Reducing Energy Consumption and Pollutant Emissions**:
- Since the "11th Five-Year Plan" (2006-2010), "energy conservation and emission reduction" has become an important goal for the development of China's energy system. However, the traditional electricity sales mechanism has, to some extent, affected the achievement of this goal. For example, in 2006, China's average coal consumption rate was 366 grams/kilowatt-hour, 50 grams/kilowatt-hour higher than the world's advanced level. By establishing a comprehensive electricity market mechanism, it is possible to better optimize dispatch, reduce coal consumption, and lower pollutant emissions.

3. **Promoting the Development of Renewable Energy**:
- With the rapid growth of wind and solar power installed capacity, the issue of renewable energy consumption has become increasingly prominent. In 2016, the curtailment rate of wind power was as high as 17.1%, with a total curtailed electricity amounting to nearly 110 terawatt-hours. This is mainly due to the traditional electricity sales mechanism, where coal-fired units enjoy government-set annual generation quotas, while the feed-in tariffs for renewable energy are higher and lack short-term market optimization. Therefore, establishing an electricity market system conducive to the development of renewable energy is an important goal of the reform.

4. **Reducing Industrial Electricity Prices**:
- In 2016, the average electricity price for industrial and commercial enterprises in China was $107/megawatt-hour, higher than that in most developing countries and even some developed countries. High electricity prices have imposed a heavy burden on the development of China's industrial and commercial sectors. By establishing a comprehensive and efficient electricity market system, it is possible to reduce the transaction costs of the traditional regulated electricity sales mechanism and further lower electricity prices.

In summary, this paper aims to analyze the background, objectives, and progress of China's electricity market reform, and to propose key challenges and recommendations for achieving these goals.