Conceptualizing Fit in Surgical Residency Selection: The Experience in Otolaryngology—Head and Neck Surgery

Jenny X. Chen,Tiffany N. Chao,Sarah N. Bowe,Nina W. Zhao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2024.04.006
IF: 3.524
2024-05-26
Journal of Surgical Education
Abstract:Objective Fit is a crucial factor in surgical residency selection, but how this abstract concept is applied in practice is poorly understood. Person-environment (PE) fit theory suggests that there are multiple fit domains that can clarify usage: person-job, person-organization, and person-workgroup fit. We used PE fit theory to explore how otolaryngology residency selection committee (RSC) members operationalize the concept of fit. Design One-hour focus groups were conducted in November 2022. Interview questions explored participants' definitions and uses of fit in the resident selection process. Transcripts were analyzed using directed qualitative content analysis to generate themes and evaluate how these align with PE fit domains. Setting Society of University Otolaryngologists Annual Meeting breakout session in November 2022. Participants 21 RSC members from 20 different otolaryngology-head and neck surgery departments participated in three seven-person focus groups. Results Participants described aspects of fit that aligned with PE fit domains. Person-job included how applicants fit as both surgeons and residents. Person-organization included how applicants fit with the program's characteristics, program's mission, and the local community. Person-workgroup emphasized how applicants fit with current residents. Various challenges in the selection process limited the extent to which PE fit was operationalized, including 1) ambiguous uses of fit, 2) unique features of the match process, 3) lack of outcomes data for selection decisions, and 4) interactions with diversity, equity, and inclusion goals. Conclusions Fit manifests in various ways during the surgical residency selection process that parallel domains of PE fit theory. Recommendations are made to assist programs in using fit in resident selection, including clearly articulating definitions of fit to increase transparency in conversations. Further work on selection challenges is needed to maximize the utility of fit in practice.
surgery,education, scientific disciplines
What problem does this paper attempt to address?