Abstract:Forensic psychiatrists are often sought by the court of law to provide professional opinion on specific legal matters that have a major impact on the evaluee and possibly society at large. The quality of that opinion and recommendations rely on the quality of the analysis from the assessment results conducted by the psychiatrist. However, the definition and scope of a forensic psychiatric analysis is not clear. While existing literature on forensic psychiatric analysis generally includes organizing information, identifying relevant details, and formulating a set of forensic psychiatric opinions as components, there is no explicit and unified definition of these terms and process. This lack of clarity and guidelines may hinder forensic psychiatry from achieving its goal of providing objective information to the court or other relevant parties. Forensic psychiatric analysis exhibits numerous parallels to clinical reasoning in other fields of medicine. Therefore, this review aims to elaborate forensic psychiatric analysis through the lens of clinical reasoning, which has been developed by incorporating advances in cognitive sciences. We describe forensic psychiatric analysis through three prominent clinical reasoning theories: hypothetico-deductive model, illness script theory, and dual process theory. We expand those theories to elucidate how forensic psychiatrists use clinical reasoning not only to diagnose mental disorders, but also to determine mental capacities as requested by law. Cognitive biases are also described as potential threat to the accuracy of the assessment and analysis. Additionally, situated cognition theory helps elucidate how contextual factors influence risk of errors. Understanding the processes involved in forensic psychiatric analysis and their pitfalls can assist forensic psychiatrists to be aware of and try to mitigate their bias. Debiasing strategies that have been implemented in other fields of medicine to mitigate errors in clinical reasoning can be adapted for forensic psychiatry. This may also shape the training program of general psychiatrists and forensic psychiatrists alike.

Social psychology in forensic practice By Joel Harvey and Derval Ambrose (Eds.), London: Routledge. 2023. pp. X+273. €31.49 (eBook). ISBN: 9781315560243; €120.00 (Hardcover). ISBN: 9781138676138. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315560243

The Cambridge Handbook of Forensic Psychology

Eyewitness Testimony

Advanced Introduction to Law and Psychology. Tom R. Tyler. Cheltenham, UK; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2022. Pp. xi, 215. ISBN: 978-1-83910-972-0. US$120.00.

Assessments in Forensic Practice: Book by K. Browne, A. Beech, L. Craig, & S. Chou

Aplicación de la Psicología forense en la evaluación criminal y su impacto en los procesos penales ecuatorianos

Perceptions of Social Climate and Aggressive Behavior in Forensic Services: A Systematic Review

Mental health and justice beyond borders: Global crises, sociopolitical determinants, and contemporary practices in forensic psychiatry

The Social Psychology of Aggression

A bibliometric analysis of research in the field of forensic psychiatry

Clinical Reasoning in Forensic Psychiatry: Concepts, Processes, and Pitfalls

Challenges of Social Workers in the Multidisciplinary Team in the Penitentiary System

The Psychology of Murder Concealment Acts

Forensic cyberpsychology and approaches to criminal profiling

The Psychology of Interrogations and Confessions: A Handbook

The Contributions of Social/Organizational Psychology to Policing

Scrutinizing Justice in Sociology: Inspiration From Social Psychology

Workplace culture for forensic mental health services: a mixed methods descriptive study

Forensic Accounting: A Novel Paradigm and Relevant Knowledge in Fraud Detection and Prevention

Applications of Legal Psychology in Japan: Current Practice, Research Knowledge, and Future Directions

New Technologies, New Problems, New Laws