Does simulation lab increase confidence in Occupational Therapy Students' clinical skills: A pilot study

Michael McKinnis,Susan Wilbanks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apmr.2024.02.607

IF: 4.06

2024-04-04

Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation

Abstract:Research Objectives To assess the impact of clinical simulation teaching modalities on OT student performance and confidence with clinical judgment and skills. Design 1 group pre-test/post-test with parallel mixed methods. Setting Health professions simulation lab in a US Midwestern University. Participants Criterion Sampling. Fifty-eight 3rd semester OT students participating in a simulation lab. Interventions Six weekly simulation experiences of increasing complexity addressing clinical judgment and skills. Prior to each simulation, students reviewed a case and created a clinical plan. Plans were reviewed with faculty prior to beginning the simulation experience. A post-experience debrief was completed with the standardized patient and faculty member. Main Outcome Measures The Acute Care Confidence Survey along with open-ended space for student comments was administered pre and post. Total scores and each subscale score (manual skills/clinical judgment/mobility/instruction) were calculated. Students' comments were analyzed for qualitative themes. Results The repeated measures ANOVA indicated a significant effect of time (F=73.9,p< 0.001). Univariate tests indicated a significant increase in confidence for the total score and all subscales (all p< 0.001). Total score+32,SD=13 and individual subscale scores: Manual skills+19,SD=18; judgement+35, SD=14; mobility+33,SD=17; instruction+36,SD=17. The primary theme observed was students recognized an improvement in performance on the individual skills addressed in survey questions. Students also acknowledged growth and the benefit of more practice. Conclusions Weekly simulation experiences that include a debrief on clinical judgment and skills are an effective teaching modality to improve the confidence of OT students. This study showed an increase in confidence in manual skills but a greater increase in confidence in judgment, mobility, and instructional skills. These results align with our curricular emphasis on manual skills for specific populations and culminating clinical decision-making activities occurring during simulated experiences. The demand for real-time decision-making is an important component of student learning instead of paper case-only assignments. We find the students' comments on the need for more practice encouraging since they still have one more didactic semester followed by 6 months of fieldwork to meet expectations of entry-level skills Author(s) Disclosures No conflicts.

rehabilitation,sport sciences