Abstract:<p>In this human subject study about interaction with head-up displays (HUDs), the impacts of three types of HUDs (flag, perspective, and flag and perspective) on experienced and inexperienced drivers were subjectively and objectively measured. The driving experiment divided 60 participants into two groups (experienced and inexperienced) and assessed their driving experiences in real high- and low-level driving tasks using the three types of HUDs. During the subjective performance evaluation, the participants executed secondary display tasks and performed a primary driving task with eye-tracking and physiological monitoring. The flag and perspective display (display FP) and the perspective display (display P) were more effective in helping drivers execute simple tasks and complex tasks, and both experienced and inexperienced drivers were HUD-dependent. Based on the study, we provided an optimized design strategy for the HUD interface. Also, we suggest the HUD design should give special consideration for inexperienced drivers.</p>

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the impact of different types of Head - Up Displays (HUDs) on the driving safety of experienced and inexperienced drivers. Specifically, through subjective and objective measurement methods, the study explored the impact of three types of HUDs (symbol display, perspective display, combined symbol and perspective display) on drivers (especially inexperienced drivers) when performing simple and complex tasks. The study aims to provide optimized HUD interface design strategies and suggests that the needs of inexperienced drivers should be specially considered when designing HUDs in order to improve driving safety. ### Research Background - **The Role of HUD**: HUDs are widely used in vehicles to reduce driver errors caused by distracting interfaces, improve road traffic safety, expand the driver's field of view, eliminate blind spots, and shorten the time of visual interference. - **Design Challenges of HUD**: New vehicle functions may increase operational complexity, leading to more distractions and safety problems. Effective HUD symbol design can effectively prevent driver distraction. - **Needs of Inexperienced Drivers**: Inexperienced drivers are more likely to be fatigued and more dependent on auxiliary systems than experienced drivers. Therefore, HUD design should pay special attention to the needs of inexperienced drivers. ### Research Methods - **Participants**: 60 drivers under the age of 30, divided into two groups, experienced and inexperienced, with 30 people in each group. - **Equipment**: A head - mounted eye tracker was used to record the right - eye movement, and a portable physiological feedback instrument was used to record the physiological state and eye - movement behavior. - **Visual Display**: Three types of HUD displays were used in the experiment: symbol display (F), combined symbol and perspective display (FP), and perspective display (P). - **Tasks**: Participants completed primary tasks (driving) and secondary tasks (involving HUD operations) on actual roads, including simple low - effort tasks and complex high - effort tasks. ### Results Analysis - **Task Completion Time**: For simple tasks, the task completion time of experienced drivers when using symbol display (F) was 3.3 seconds shorter than that of inexperienced drivers (p = 0.014). For complex tasks, the task completion time of experienced drivers under all three display methods was significantly shorter than that of inexperienced drivers. - **NASA - TLX Score**: The total NASA - TLX workload scores of experienced drivers under all display methods were lower than those of inexperienced drivers. The workload score of symbol display (F) was significantly higher than that of combined symbol and perspective display (FP) and perspective display (P). ### Conclusions - **The Impact of HUD on Driving Safety**: The combined symbol and perspective display (FP) and perspective display (P) are more effective in helping drivers perform simple and complex tasks and have a significant impact on both experienced and inexperienced drivers. - **Design Recommendations**: The study provides optimized HUD interface design strategies and suggests that the needs of inexperienced drivers should be specially considered when designing HUDs in order to improve driving safety.

Effects of perception of head-up display on the driving safety of experienced and inexperienced drivers

Effects of Head-Up Display Information Layout Design on Driver Performance: Driving Simulator Studies

Head-up Display Graphic Warning System Facilitates Simulated Driving Performance

Effects of using head-up display in automobile context on attention demand and driving performance

Effects of full windshield head-up display on visual attention allocation

Isolating the Effect of Off-Road Glance Duration on Driving Performance: An Exemplar Study Comparing HDD and HUD in Different Driving Scenarios

Are Warnings Suitable for Presentation in Head-Up Display? A Meta-Analysis for the Effect of Head-Up Display Warning on Driving Performance

Comparison of head-up display (HUD) vs. head-down display (HDD): driving performance of commercial vehicle operators in Taiwan

The Effects of Head-Up Display Clutter and In-Vehicle Display Separation on Concurrent Driving Performance

How does AR-HUD system affect driving behaviour Evidence from an eye-tracking experiment study

Effect of Warning Graphics Location on Driving Performance: An Eye Movement Study

Parallax of Head-Up Displays and Visual Safety for Driving

Effects of Various In-Vehicle Human-Machine Interfaces on Drivers' Takeover Performance and Gaze Pattern in Conditionally Automated Vehicles

Improving Pedestrian Safety with Head-Up Display Warning in a Connected Environment

Head-up display with dynamic depth-variable viewing effect

Get Ready for Take-Overs: Using Head-Up Display for Drivers to Engage in Non-Driving-Related Tasks in Automated Vehicles

Design of head-up display interfaces for automated vehicles

Investigation of Text-Background Lightness Combination on Visual Clarity Using a Head-Up Display under Various Surround Conditions and Different Age Groups

Drivers' gaze patterns when resuming control with a head-up-display: Effects of automation level and time budget

Head-Up Display for Pilots and Drivers

Visual Complexity of Head-Up Display in Automobiles Modulates Attentional Tunneling