Abstract:In this study, we assessed whether the trust model formed by children in a moral judgment context with an inaccurate in-group informant affected their corresponding trust model in the knowledge access context and whether conditions (the presence of conflicting testimony: an inaccurate in-group informant paired with an accurate out-group informant; the absence of conflicting testimony: only an inaccurate in-group informant) influenced the trust model. Children aged 3 to 6 years (N = 215; 108 girls) in blue T-shirts as in-group members completed selective trust tasks in the moral judgment and knowledge access contexts. Results for moral judgment showed that children under both conditions were more likely to trust informants based on accurate judgments and gave less consideration to group identity. Results for knowledge access showed that in the presence of conflicting testimony, 3- and 4-year-olds trusted the in-group informant at chance, but 5- and 6-year-olds trusted the accurate informant. In the absence of conflicting testimony, 3- and 4-year-olds agreed more with the inaccurate in-group informant, but 5- and 6-year-olds trusted the in-group informant at chance. The results indicated that older children considered the accuracy of the informant's previous moral judgment for selective trust in the context of knowledge access while ignoring group identity, but that younger children were affected by in-group identity. The study found that 3- to 6-year-olds' trust in inaccurate in-group informants was conditional and that their trust choices appeared to be experimentally conditioned, domain specific, and age differentiated. (c) 2023 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Inc. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecom-mons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).

Trusting information from friends: Adults expect it but preschoolers do not.

Updating trust: How children combine trait information with prior accuracy as they interact with an informant.

Do Preschoolers Always Trust the Majority? the Influence of Familiarity and Expertise of a Dissenter in a Chinese Sample

Children Infer Intentions by Assessing Epistemic Attitudes in Interpersonal Interactions

School-age children are more skeptical of inaccurate robots than adults

When the internet is wrong: Children's trust in an inaccurate internet or human source

Children presume confident informants will be accurate (until proven otherwise)

Impact of Bystander's Non-verbal Cues on Preschoolers' Selective Trust

Says who? Children consider informants' sources when deciding whom to believe.

Children weigh internet inaccuracy when trusting in online information

In the Presence and Absence of Conflicting Testimony, Children's Selective Trust in the In-Group Informant in Moral Judgment and Knowledge Access.

Robot teachers for children? Young children trust robots depending on their perceived accuracy and agency.

Never trust a stranger: Effects of explicit belief statements from strangers on children's reality status beliefs and beliefs about consensus

Selective trust: Children's use of intention and outcome of past testimony.

Children's Social Epistemology: Children's Selective Trust in Informants

On a need‐to‐know basis: Young children distinguish conventional and privileged information

Development of Preschool Children's Selective Trust Based on Judgments of Information -Its Continuity and Its Relationship with Interpersonal Trust

Someone who knows and someone I trust: Investigating how and with whom U.S. 8- to 14-year-old youth seek to learn about racial inequality.

When Trust Fails: The Relation Between Children’s Trust Beliefs in Peers and their Peer Interactions in a Natural Setting

Trusting young children to help causes them to cheat less

Old Friends, New Friends: Predictors of Children's Perspective on Their Friends at School