Abstract:In social economic decisions, people not only care about their own payoffs but also the payoffs of others, a tendency termed altruistic preference. Numerous studies have shown that the sheer sense of being observed is sufficient to augment subjects' altruistic choices. However, whether subjects' altruistic behavior can be modulated by other stake-holders in the decision context remains unclear. In this study, we provide experimental evidence about the effects of visibility from receivers and social norms on the altruistic preference of the deciders in two studies. First, we confirmed the visibility effect originating from receivers on deciders' altruistic preference in Study 1. In Study 2, we further showed that social norms modulated the effect of behavior visibility on deciders' altruistic preference, suggesting a potential avenue via which social norms influence the relationship between behavioral visibility and altruistic preference. Study 1 implemented a 2 ( visibility: visible vs. invisible) x 2 (reaction type: choice vs. rating) x 2 (inequity aversion: AIA vs. DIA) within-subject design. We recruited 38 participants and they were required to either choose from two reward allocation options (choice task) with another partner, or rate how satisfied concerning a particular allocation (rating task) in a dictator game (DG). Participants' behavior was either observed by their "partners" (visible condition) or remained private (invisible condition). We provided both model-free and model-based evidence for the effects of visibility on altruistic preference. Compared to the invisible condition, participants exhibited greater altruistic preference when their behavior were visible to the receivers (partners). This tendency was significant across both choice and rating tasks. In addition, participants cared more about allocation efficiency in the choice task than in the rating task. Finally, visibility alleviated the behavioral discrepancies between the rating and choice tasks, indicating that social preference and choice strategies tend to converge in the visible condition. Study 2 implemented a 2 (visibility: visible vs. invisible) x 2 ( social norm: altruistic vs. non-altruistic) within- subject design. 53 participants took part in the study with altruistic or non-altruistic social norms. Different social norms were manipulated by presenting the proportions of choosing the unfair options from previous participants: In the altruistic social norm condition, most previous participants chose the option that maximizes others' relative payoffs, while in the non- altruistic condition it was the opposite. Our results showed that in the altruistic social norm condition, visibility significantly increased participants' altruistic preference. However, such effect diminished in the non-altruistic social norm condition. Our study revealed that deciders' behavioral visibility to receivers increased altruistic preference and promoted altruistic behavior. Furthermore, the altruistic social norm played a modulatory role on the visibility effect, supporting the signaling hypothesis of altruistic preference.

Social appropriateness with contractual incompleteness

Informal Lending, Interdependent Utility and Other-Regarding Motives: Further Evidence from an In-the-field Choice Experiment in Rural China

The Cultural Transmission of Cooperative Norms

Socially Appropriate Intervention: A Cross-Country Investigation of Third-Party Norm Enforcement

Elicitation of normative and fairness judgments: Do incentives matter?

Culture Differences and Individual Choice:An Empirical Study Based on Game Theory

Confusion cannot explain cooperative behavior in public goods games

Social Norm Modulates the Enhancement Effect of Behavioral Visibility on Altruistic Preference

Social Norm Design for Information Exchange Systems with Limited Observations

Reputation update of responders efficiently promotes the evolution of fairness in the ultimatum game

The Boundaries of Good Deeds:Public Good Choices in Conflicts between Social Norms and Market Norms-A Study of Students from Shanghai Jiao Tong University

The effect of third-party intervention on normative behavior of bystanders: An explanation of the social norm cueing effect

Tolerance for corruption and descriptive social norm: An experimental study of embezzlement

Norm talk and human cooperation: Can we talk ourselves into cooperation?

Interactions between social norms and incentive mechanisms in organizations

To qualify as a social partner, humans hide severe punishment, although their observed cooperativeness is decisive

Variance, norms and cooperative behavior in public goods games

Perceiving high social mindfulness during interpersonal interaction promotes cooperative behaviours

Endogenous monitoring through voluntary reporting in an infinitely repeated prisoner's dilemma game: experimental evidence

Self-Conscious or Fear of Hurting Another’s Feeling? An Experimental Investigation on Promise-Keeping

Social comparisons differentially affect fair and unfair processing in ultimatum bargaining