Objective Determination of Star Formation Histories

Gerard Gilmore,Xavier Hernandez,David Valls-Gabaud

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A%3A1002677120069

1999-08-20

Abstract:Objective determination of a star formation history from a colour-magnitude diagram, independently of assumed parametric descriptions, is necessary to determine the evolutionary history of a galaxy. We introduce a new method for solving maximum likelihood problems through variational calculus, and apply it to the case of recovering an unknown star formation history, SFR(t), from a colour-magnitude diagram. This method provides a non-parametric solution with the advantage of requiring no initial assumptions on the SFR(t). As a full maximum likelihood statistical model is used, one may exploit all the information available in the photometric data which can be explained by available isochrones. Extensive tests of the method show it to be reliable under noise conditions comparable to those appropriate for real observations. Implications for future surveys, such as the GAIA mission are significant: accurate determination of the evolutionary history of the Milky Way is limited only by adequate spectroscopy and/or photometry to provide a determination of stellar metallicity and temperature for a sufficient sample of stars of luminosities at and above an old main-sequence turnoff.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to objectively determine the star formation history (SFH) from the color - magnitude diagram (C - M diagram) of galaxies without relying on pre - assumed parametric descriptions.

Specifically, the authors introduced a new method based on variational calculus to solve the maximum - likelihood problem and applied it to recover the unknown star formation rate \(SFR(t)\) from the C - M diagram. The advantage of this method is that it does not require any initial assumptions about \(SFR(t)\) and can make full use of all the information in the photometric data, which can be interpreted by the available isochrones.

### Key problems and challenges

1. **Non - parametric solution**:
- Traditional methods usually rely on preset parametric models, which may introduce subjectivity and limit the accuracy of the results.
- The method proposed in this paper provides a non - parametric solution, avoiding this subjectivity.

2. **Data quality and noise**:
- The method needs to be still reliable under noise conditions comparable to actual observation conditions.
- Through extensive testing, the reliability of this method under noise conditions has been verified.

3. **Age - metallicity degeneracy**:
- The degeneracy problem between age and metallicity is a major challenge in inferring star formation history.
- Research shows that for very old star populations, the color is less sensitive to age differences, so higher photometric accuracy is required.

4. **Application in future surveys**:
- This method is of great significance for future large - scale surveys (such as the GAIA mission) and can accurately determine the evolution history of the Milky Way.
- Accurate determination of star metallicity and temperature is crucial for obtaining a reliable star formation history.

### Conclusion

By introducing the variational calculus method, the authors have successfully solved the problem of recovering star formation history from the C - M diagram. This method performs well when dealing with young star populations (< 10 Gyr), while for older star populations, higher photometric accuracy is required. In addition, the effectiveness of this method depends on the independently determined star metallicity to overcome the age - metallicity degeneracy problem.

In summary, this paper aims to develop an objective and reliable method that does not rely on preset parametric models for inferring star formation history from the C - M diagram, so as to better understand the evolution process of galaxies.