Abstract:The dipole moment of any finite and neutral system, having a square-integrable wavefunction, is a well defined quantity. The same quantity is ill-defined for an extended system, whose wavefunction invariably obeys periodic (Born-von Karman) boundary conditions. Despite this fact, macroscopic polarization is a theoretically accessible quantity, for either uncorrelated or correlated many-electron systems: in both cases, polarization is a rather "exotic" observable. For an uncorrelated-either Hartree-Fock or Kohn-Sham-crystalline solid, polarization has been expressed and computed as a Berry phase of the Bloch orbitals (since 1993). The case of a correlated and/or disordered system received a definitive solution only very recently (1998): this latest development allows us present here the whole theory from a novel, and very general, viewpoint. The modern theory of polarization is even relevant to the foundations of density functional theory in extended systems.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is about how to define and calculate macroscopic polarization in extended systems (such as macroscopic solids). Specifically, the paper has solved the following key issues:
1. **Differences between finite systems and extended systems**:
- For any finite and neutral system, its dipole moment is a well - defined quantity. However, for an extended system following periodic boundary conditions (Born - von Kármán boundary conditions), the dipole moment is undefined.
- The paper points out that although the wave function of the extended system satisfies the periodic boundary conditions, which makes the dipole moment unable to be directly defined by integration, the macroscopic polarization is still a theoretically accessible physical quantity.
2. **Polarization of independent - electron systems and correlated - electron systems**:
- For non - correlated multi - electron systems (such as Hartree - Fock or Kohn - Sham crystalline solids), polarization can be expressed as the Berry phase of Bloch orbitals and can already be calculated by this method.
- For correlated - electron systems or disordered systems, there was no clear solution until 1998. The paper provides a method to re - examine the entire theory from a new, more general perspective.
3. **The problem of the position operator under periodic boundary conditions**:
- Due to the existence of periodic boundary conditions, the position operator in quantum mechanics becomes unbounded, resulting in the integral being undefined when directly using the dipole moment formula (such as equation (1)).
- The paper introduces a complex number \( z \), defined as:
\[
z=\langle\psi|e^{i\frac{2\pi}{L}x}|\psi\rangle = \int_{0}^{L}dx\,e^{i\frac{2\pi}{L}x}|\psi(x)|^{2}
\]
and defines the position expectation value through the phase of \( z \):
\[
\langle x\rangle=\frac{L}{2\pi}\Im\ln z
\]
4. **The definition of macroscopic polarization and its relationship with experiments**:
- Macroscopic polarization is usually not measured as an absolute quantity, but is measured through its derivative or difference, such as dielectric constant, pyroelectric effect, piezoelectric effect, etc.
- The paper gives the definition of polarization difference:
\[
\Delta P=\int_{0}^{\Delta t}dt\,J(t)
\]
where \( J(t) \) is the current flowing through the sample under a slowly varying potential.
5. **The polarization problem in density functional theory (DFT)**:
- The paper discusses the impact of the polarization problem on DFT. In particular, when the system adopts periodic boundary conditions, polarization is no longer a function of density, which leads to the polarization difference between the Kohn - Sham (KS) system and the real interacting system.
In summary, this paper aims to provide a new, more general method to define and calculate macroscopic polarization in extended systems, solving the long - standing challenges in electronic structure theory.