Abstract:Ionic crystals play a central role in functional applications. Mesoscale descriptions of these crystals are based on the continuum polarization density field to represent the effective physics of charge distribution at the scale of the atomic lattice. However, a long-standing difficulty is that the classical electrostatic definition of the macroscopic polarization -- as the dipole or first moment of the charge density in a unit cell -- is not unique. This unphysical non-uniqueness has been shown to arise from starting directly with an infinite system rather than starting with a finite body and taking appropriate limits. This limit process shows that the electrostatic description requires not only the bulk polarization density, but also the surface charge density, as the effective macroscopic descriptors; that is, a nonlocal effective description. Other approaches to resolve this difficulty include relating the change in polarization to the transport of charge; or, to define the polarization as the energy-conjugate to the electric field. This work examines the relation between the classical electrostatic definition of polarization, and the transport and energy-conjugate definitions of polarization. We show the following: (1) The transport of charge does not correspond to the change in polarization in general; instead, one requires additional simplifying assumptions on the electrostatic definition of polarization for these approaches to give rise to the same macroscopic electric fields. Thus, the electrostatic definition encompasses the transport definition as a special case. (2) The energy-conjugate definition has both bulk and surface contributions; while traditional approaches neglect the surface contribution, we find that accounting for the nonlocal surface contributions is essential to obtain the correct macroscopic electric fields.

Macroscopic Polarization from Electronic Wavefunctions

One-dimensional Moving Polarons with Extended Coherent States

Nonuniqueness in Defining the Polarization: Nonlocal Surface Charges and the Electrostatic, Energetic, and Transport Perspectives

Perspective: From the dipole of a crystallite to the polarization of a crystal

Macroscopic Polarization from Nonlinear Gradient Couplings

Polarization at the Nanoscale

Local approaches for electric dipole moments in periodic systems and their application to real-time time-dependent density functional theory

Polar liquid crystals in two spatial dimensions: the bridge from microscopic to macroscopic modeling

Unraveling a cavity induced molecular polarization mechanism from collective vibrational strong coupling

A Molecular Contact Theory for Simulating Polarization: Application to Dielectric Constant Prediction.

Charge redistribution and polarization energy of organic molecular crystals

Phenomena in Polarized Disperse Systems Caused by Exchange-Correlation Interaction between Particles

A comprehensive theory for relativistic polaritonic chemistry: a four components ab initio treatment of molecular systems coupled to quantum fields

A Unified Description for Polarization-Transfer Mechanisms in Magnetic Resonance in Static Solids: Cross Polarization and DNP

Polaritonic response theory for exact and approximate wave functions

Surface polarization strongly influences electrostatics in a nonlocal medium

Non-Aqueous Ion Pairing Exemplifies the Case for Including Electronic Polarization in Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov Theory of Polarized Fermi Systems

Splay and polar order in a system of hard pear-like molecules: confrontation of Monte Carlo numerical simulations with density functional theory calculations

Momentum Polarization: an Entanglement Measure of Topological Spin and Chiral Central Charge