Do Jet-Driven Shocks ionize the Narrow Line Regions of Seyfert Galaxies?

A. S. Wilson,J. C. Raymond

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/311923

1999-01-23

Abstract:We consider a model in which the narrow line regions (NLRs) of Seyfert galaxies are photoionized ``in situ'' by fast (300 -- 1,000 km/s), radiative shock waves driven into the interstellar medium of the galaxy by radio jets from the active nucleus. Such shocks are powerful sources of soft X-rays. We compute the expected ratio of the count rates in the ROSAT PSPC and Einstein IPC detectors to the [OIII] \lambda 5007 flux as a function of shock velocity, and compare these ratios with observations of type 2 Seyferts. If most of the observed soft X-ray emission from these galaxies originates in the NLR and the absorbing hydrogen column is similar to that inferred from the reddening of the NLR, a photoionizing shock model with shock velocity $\simeq$ 400 -- 500 km/s is compatible with the observed ratios. High angular resolution observations with AXAF are needed to isolate the X-ray emission of the NLR and measure its absorbing column, thus providing a more conclusive test. We also calculate the expected coronal iron line emission from the shocks. For most Seyfert 2s, the [Fe X] \lambda 6374/H \beta$ ratio is a factor of 2 -- 14 lower than the predictions of 300 -- 500 km/s shock models, suggesting that less hot gas is present than required by these models.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Is the narrow - line region (NLR) of Seyfert galaxies in active galactic nuclei (AGN) ionized by shocks driven by radio jets?** Specifically, the author explored whether the gas in the NLR is mainly ionized by the radiative ionization of high - speed shocks (300 - 1,000 km/s), rather than by traditional compact photoionization sources (such as accretion disks).

### Main problems and background

1. **Ionization mechanism of NLR**:
- The traditional view is that the gas in the NLR is ionized by a compact photoionization source (such as an accretion disk).
- However, research in the past 20 years has shown that there is a strong correlation between the narrow emission lines and radio continuum properties of Seyfert galaxies, suggesting that radio jets may be related to the ionization of the NLR.

2. **Proposal of the shock model**:
- The author proposed a model in which the gas in the NLR is ionized by the radiative ionization of high - speed shocks (300 - 1,000 km/s). These shocks are driven by radio jets emitted by active galactic nuclei.
- Shocks will not only ionize the gas but also produce a large amount of soft X - rays, which provides an important observational indicator for verifying this model.

### Key issues

- **Relationship between soft X - rays and [OIII] λ5007 emission line**:
- The paper calculated the ratio of the count rates of ROSAT PSPC and Einstein IPC detectors to the [OIII] λ5007 emission line flux at different shock velocities and compared it with the observational data.
- If most of the observed soft X - rays do indeed originate from the NLR and the hydrogen column density is similar to that inferred from the optical narrow lines, then the model with a shock velocity of approximately 400 - 500 km/s is consistent with the observational results.

- **Iron coronal line emission**:
- The model predicts that shocks will produce strong iron coronal line emissions, such as [Fe X] λ6374 and [Fe XIV] λ5303.
- Observational results show that the [Fe X] λ6374/Hβ ratio in most Seyfert 2 - type galaxies is 2 - 14 times lower than the model prediction, which may indicate that there is less hot gas in reality than predicted by the model, or more support for the traditional photoionization model.

### Conclusion

The paper explored whether radio - jet - driven shocks can explain the ionization phenomenon in the NLR by comparing model predictions with observational data. Although the shock model is consistent with the observations in some aspects, the observational results of iron coronal line emissions pose a challenge to the shock model. Future higher - resolution observations will help to further verify this model.

### Formula summary

- **Relationship between shock velocity and X - ray flux**:
\[
R=\frac{\text{X - ray count rate}}{\text{[OIII]}\lambda5007\text{ flux}}
\]
where \(R\) is the ratio of the X - ray count rate to the [OIII] λ5007 emission line flux, which varies with the shock velocity.

- **Iron coronal line emission intensity**:
\[
\text{[Fe X]}\lambda6374/H\beta\quad\text{and}\quad\text{[Fe XIV]}\lambda5303/H\beta
\]
These ratios are used to evaluate the consistency between the shock model and the observational data.