Following Physician's Advice in Late Life: The Roles of Health Beliefs and Health Status
Poshan Dahal,Eva Kahana
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ppa.s409023
2024-01-21
Patient Preference and Adherence
Abstract:Poshan Dahal, Eva Kahana Department of Sociology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA Correspondence: Poshan Dahal, Department of Sociology, Case Western Reserve University, 226 Mather Memorial Building, 10900 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH, 44106-7124, USA, Tel +1-216-368-2000, Email Objective: This study aims to explore the influence of health-related locus of control beliefs such as belief in the role of health professionals in influencing patient health, cognitive functioning, and multimorbidity on adherence to physician's recommendations among older adults. Methods: A cross-sectional study involving older adults (N=684, age range = 71– 100 years) living in Clearwater, Florida, reported their adherence to physician's recommendations, cognitive functioning, physical health, and health-related locus of control beliefs. Ordered Logistic regression was used. Results: Older adults who believed that health professionals influence health and a person is likely to recover from illness because other people take good care of him/her had higher adherence to physician's recommendations. Older adults who believed that their own action affects their health had lower odds of reporting adherence by 27%. Additionally, those with cognitive impairment had lower odds of reporting adherence by 38%. Functional limitations, multimorbidity, and self-image of health were not associated with adherence. Conclusion: This is one of the first studies to consider the influence of locus of control beliefs on adherence of physician's recommendations among community dwelling older adults. With the exception of one item "My good health is largely a matter of good fortune", generally individuals with external locus of control had higher adherence. Our findings also underscore the policy and clinical significance of different health-related beliefs held by older adults. Keywords: health behaviors, adherence, health beliefs, older adults, ordered logistic regression Adherence to health-related recommendations, such as medication, diet, and lifestyle changes, has profound implication for improving health outcomes. 1–4 High prevalence of chronic illnesses and increased vulnerability to health issues with age make adherence to such recommendations even more important for older adults. Health-related recommendations such as medication adherence are critical since non-adherence among older adults with chronic conditions can have serious health consequences. 5 Despite the importance of adherence to physician's recommendations, studies have shown mixed results about the prevalence and predictors of non-adherence among older adults. 6–10 Previous studies have identified various factors associated with patient adherence. These include knowledge or health literacy, 11 cognitive function, 12 patient–provider relationship, 13 patient's perception of physician, 14 adverse effects of drugs or polypharmacy and lack of confidence in immediate or future benefits 15 and other logistics and economic barriers. 16 Some of the barriers to adherence may relate to a perceived lack of need. The older person who is in good health may not be concerned about health-related vulnerability. 17 Other barriers may involve beliefs about locus of control, which refer to the extent to which people believe that they have control over their own fate. 18 In this study context, it refers to the control people believe they have over their health. Prior research has focused on the role of health care provider on patient's adherence to medical regimens and did not consider patient's beliefs. 19 Having strong internal locus of control beliefs may empower older adults to follow medical advice and thereby enhance their health. Conversely, strong external locus of control beliefs may result in aversion to focus on health behaviors and greater reliance on others. Findings about the association between locus of control and health care utilizations among older adults are mixed. 20–22 Chipperfield and Greenslade 23 explored the connection between locus of control and health care utilization. They found that older adults who had low level of internal locus of control had higher use of health care services – visited physicians more often, had more laboratory tests, and stayed longer in the hospital. Hong et al, 24 in a study of anti-hypertensive medication use found more adherence among individuals with higher internal locus of control and lower external locus of control. De Jesus and Xiao 20 on the other hand found a weak impact of health-related locus of control on health care utilization after accounting for access to health insuran -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal