Field Trial Evaluation of a Hybrid Heat Pump in an Existing Multi-Family House before and after Renovation

Daniel Neubert,Christian Glück,Jeannette Wapler,Armin Marko,Constanze Bongs,Clemens Felsmann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17061502

IF: 3.2

2024-03-22

Energies

Abstract:Renovation of existing buildings is fundamental to reduce greenhouse gas emissions of the building sector and to ensure the efficient operation of renewable heating systems. In multi-family houses, the suitability of heat pumps is limited by high required temperatures for the hot water preparation, which can be mitigated by hybrid heat pump systems. In this study, the energetic performance of a hybrid heat pump in a multi-family house, built in 1964, is investigated based on field data before and after a renovation. Multiple months are measured and mapped to a full year period. The combination of different renovation measures in the heating system and building envelope is rated w.r.t. their ecological and economical impact by taking into account the actual investment costs. The evaluation shows that the installation of a hybrid heat pump can achieve an accumulated greenhouse gas emissions reduction of 45%, which is similar to a building renovation to a new-build standard, which reduces the space heating demand by up to 62%. Nevertheless, only a combination of both measures can substantially reduce the emissions, which in this case are 81% lower compared to a gas boiler in 1990, which is still below the German climate target for 2040. Due to the low investment costs of a hybrid heat pump system, tenants are more likely to profit from a renting costs reduction, while a building renovation is especially economically beneficial at high energy prices. The results therefore emphasize that the insulation level should be selected carefully, as heat pumps already prepare space heating efficiently and that the heat pump must be able to support the hot water preparation to reach high emission reduction targets.

energy & fuels

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of evaluating the energy efficiency performance of installing hybrid heat pump systems in existing multi-family residential buildings before and after renovation, and to assess their ecological and economic impacts in conjunction with building envelope retrofit measures.

Specifically:
1. **Emission Reduction Targets**: The study aims to achieve greenhouse gas emission reduction targets by installing hybrid heat pump systems, particularly through comparative analysis before and after renovation.
2. **Energy Efficiency Evaluation**: By analyzing actual measurement data, the study evaluates the energy efficiency of hybrid heat pump systems.
3. **Economic Evaluation**: Considering the actual investment costs, the study assesses the economic benefits of hybrid heat pump systems compared to traditional boiler systems.
4. **Comprehensive Measures Effectiveness**: In conjunction with building envelope retrofits (such as exterior walls, roofs, etc.), the study evaluates the comprehensive effects of these measures on energy saving and emission reduction.

The study found that installing hybrid heat pumps alone can achieve approximately 45% greenhouse gas emission reduction, while combining with building renovation can achieve up to 81% reduction. Additionally, due to the lower investment costs of hybrid heat pump systems, tenants are more likely to benefit from reduced rent. However, building renovation is more economically advantageous under high energy prices. Therefore, the study emphasizes the importance of insulation selection and the necessity of ensuring that heat pumps can support hot water supply to achieve high emission reduction targets.