Thermal, Electrical, and Economic Performance of a Hybrid Solar-Wind-Geothermal System: Case Study of a Detached House in Hamburg and Sylt, Germany

Linwei Hu,Niklas Tischler,Zarghaam Haider Rizvi,Johannes Nordbeck,Frank Wuttke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17122856

IF: 3.2

2024-06-12

Energies

Abstract:Germany is undergoing an energy transition. By 2045, fossil fuels will be gradually replaced by clean energy. An alternative option is to use geothermal, solar and wind energy to generate heat or electricity. Currently, an economic model that considers these three energy sources and incorporates the design and installation of the energy system as well as operational costing focusing on the local market is lacking. In this study, we present a concept for a hybrid energy system combining solar, wind and geothermal energy for small, detached houses. We also develop a simplified economic model for the German market and local energy subsidy policies. The model was applied to two different cities in northern Germany, calculating the installation and long-term operating costs of different energy systems and combinations over a period of 100 years, including the consideration of the lifespan of variable equipment. The calculations show that for this small hybrid energy system the initial installation costs can vary from EUR 20,344 to EUR 70,186 depending on different portfolios. Long-term operating costs come mainly from electricity purchased from the grid to compensate for periods of low solar or wind production. In addition, the study included a calculation of the payback period for retrofitting a natural gas heating system. Results show that combining a photovoltaic system with a ground source heat pump, especially in the form of a near-surface heat exchanger, yields a shorter payback period (5 to 10 years). However, the incorporation of on-roof wind turbines into the hybrid energy system may significantly prolong the payback period and is therefore not recommended for use in low wind speed areas.

energy & fuels

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to use three renewable energy sources, namely geothermal energy, solar energy and wind energy, to provide heat and electricity for detached houses in the context of Germany's energy transition, and develop a simplified economic model to evaluate the installation and long - term operation costs of these systems. Specifically, the objectives of the paper include:

1. **Design a hybrid energy system**: Combine solar energy, wind energy and geothermal energy to provide heat and electricity for two detached houses in Hamburg and Sylt in northern Germany.
2. **Develop an economic model**: Develop a simplified economic model for the German market and local energy subsidy policies to evaluate the installation and long - term operation costs of different energy systems.
3. **Evaluate the cost - effectiveness of different energy combinations**: Evaluate the economic feasibility of various combinations by calculating the initial installation cost, long - term operation cost and payback period of different energy combinations.
4. **Consider the service life of equipment**: Consider the service life of various equipment in the economic model to evaluate the long - term cost more accurately.

### Main research contents

- **Energy demand analysis**: Assume that the structures and energy efficiency levels of the two houses are the same, and analyze their annual heat and electricity demands.
- **Hybrid energy system design**: Propose a scheme using ground - source heat pumps, solar photovoltaic panels and rooftop wind turbines to maximize the energy demands of the houses.
- **Climate and geological data evaluation**: Use local meteorological and soil data to evaluate the power generation potential of solar and wind energy and the heat energy potential of geothermal energy.
- **Economic model construction**: Construct an economic model based on the German market and policies to evaluate the installation and long - term operation costs of different energy systems.
- **Cost - effectiveness analysis**: Compare the initial installation cost, long - term operation cost and payback period of different energy combinations to evaluate their economic feasibility.

### Key formulas

- **Calculation of solar power generation**:
\[
E_{\text{sp}} = Q_{\text{sp}} \cdot A_{\text{sp}} \cdot h_{\text{peak}} \cdot \epsilon_{\text{sp}}
\]
where \( Q_{\text{sp}} \) is the load per square meter of solar panel (about 0.2 kWp/m²), \( A_{\text{sp}} \) is the area of the solar panel (assumed to be 33 m²), \( h_{\text{peak}} \) is the number of daily peak sunshine hours, and \( \epsilon_{\text{sp}} \) is the efficiency of the system (assumed to be 80%).

- **Calculation of wind power generation**:
\[
E_{\text{w}} = 5.2273 \cdot v_{\text{w}}^2 - 46.591 \cdot v_{\text{w}} + 116.73
\]
where \( v_{\text{w}} \) is the wind speed (m/s), and \( E_{\text{w}} \) is the power generation (kWh). The starting speed of the wind turbine is 4 m/s, and it does not generate electricity when the speed is lower than this.

- **Total cost calculation**:
- **Scenario 1** (Gas - fired boiler for heating, power grid for power supply):
\[
\text{TC}_{\text{gb},i} = \sum_{i = 1}^{N} \left( \text{OMC}_{\text{gb},i} + E_{\text{ea},i} \cdot P_{\text{grid}} \right)
\]
- **Scenario 2** (Solar - wind - geothermal energy coupling system):
\[
\text{TC}_{\text{swg},i} = \sum_{k} \text{IC}_k + \sum_{k} \sum_{i = 1}^{N} (\text{OMC}_{k,i}) + \sum_{i = 1}^{N} (\text{OC}_{\text{ea},i} - R_{\text{fd},i})
\]