On Phase Transition and Self-Organized Critical State in Granular Packings

Einat Aharonov,David Sparks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/9812204

1998-12-12

Abstract:We model two-dimensional systems of granular aggregates confined between two planes and demonstrate that at a critical grain volume fraction an abrupt rigidity transition occurs. This transition is observed both in static and shear tests. The grain volume fraction at which the transition occurs, $\nu_c$, decreases with increasing friction between the grains. Densely packed grains, with a volume fraction $\nu> \nu_c$, display an elastic-plastic rheology. Dilute packings, with $\nu<\nu_c$, display gas-like characteristics. Packings with $\nu=\nu_c$ display phase coexistance. It is shown that when volume fraction is allowed to change freely (using constant normal stress boundary condition), it evolves spontaneously to $\nu_c$ under a wide range of boundary conditions, exhibiting 'self-organized criticality'.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the phase - change behavior of granular matter under different conditions and its self - organized critical state. Specifically, through numerical simulation, the researchers studied the sudden transition of the two - dimensional granular system from gas - like behavior to solid - like behavior when the granular volume fraction reaches a certain critical value \( \nu_c \) in both static and shear tests. This transition was observed not only under static conditions but also was evident in shear tests.

### Main problems solved in the paper:
1. **Rigidity transition of the granular system**: The researchers found that when the granular volume fraction \( \nu \) reaches a critical value \( \nu_c \), the granular system will undergo a sudden rigidity transition. This critical value \( \nu_c \) decreases as the friction coefficient between granules increases.
2. **System behavior at different volume fractions**: For sparse systems with \( \nu < \nu_c \), their behavior is similar to that of a gas; while for dense systems with \( \nu > \nu_c \), their behavior shows elastoplastic characteristics.
3. **Self - organized critical state**: When the volume fraction is allowed to change freely, the system will spontaneously evolve to the critical volume fraction \( \nu_c \), showing "self - organized criticality".
4. **Transition of dynamic behavior**: The researchers also explored the behavior change of the granular system near the critical volume fraction under shear conditions. In particular, when \( \nu=\nu_c \), the system will oscillate between solid - like and gas - like states, showing the coexistence of solid and gas states.

### Key findings:
- **Critical volume fraction**: The critical volume fraction \( \nu_c \) is determined to be between 0.80 and 0.84, and the specific value depends on the friction coefficient between granules.
- **Change in coordination number**: The coordination number \( Z \) near the critical volume fraction \( \nu_c \) suddenly increases and has a power - law relationship with \( \nu-\nu_c \).
- **Abrupt change in shear modulus**: The shear modulus \( G \) of the system jumps from zero to a finite value when \( \nu = \nu_c \), indicating the transition of the system from disorder to order.
- **Dynamic behavior**: Under shear conditions, sparse systems (\( \nu < \nu_c \)) show short - lived collisions, while dense systems (\( \nu > \nu_c \)) show elastoplastic cycles and the formation of stress chains.
- **Self - organized criticality**: Under the condition of constant normal stress, the system will spontaneously evolve to the critical volume fraction \( \nu_c \) and show the coexistence of solid and gas states in this state.

Through these studies, the paper reveals the complex behavior of granular systems under different conditions and provides an important theoretical basis for understanding the granular dynamics in natural and technological systems.