Abstract:Granular systems confined in vertically vibrated shallow horizontal boxes (quasi two-dimensional geometry) present a liquid to solid phase transition when the frequency of the periodic forcing is increased. An effective model, where grains move and collide in two-dimensions is presented, which reproduces the aforementioned phase transition. The key element is that besides the two-dimensional degrees of freedom, each grain has an additional variable $\epsilon$ that accounts for the kinetic energy stored in the vertical motion in the real quasi two-dimensional motion. This energy grows monotonically during free flight, mimicking the energy gain by collisions with the vibrating walls and, at collisions, this energy is instantaneously transferred to the horizontal degrees of freedom. As a result, the average values of $\epsilon$ and the kinetic temperature are decreasing functions of the local density, giving rise to an effective pressure that can present van der Waals loops. A kinetic theory approach predicts the conditions that must satisfy the energy grow function to obtain the phase separation, which are verified with molecular dynamics simulations. Notably, the effective equation of state and the critical points computed considering the velocity--time-of-flight correlations differ only slightly from those obtained by simple kinetic theory calculations that neglect those correlations.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to address the issue of non-equilibrium phase transitions of granular materials from liquid to solid state in a quasi two-dimensional (Q2D) shallow box under vertical vibrations. Specifically, as the vibration frequency increases, the system undergoes phase separation, forming dense and sparse phases. The sparse phase exhibits a crystalline structure similar to a solid. The paper proposes an effective two-dimensional model that can reproduce this phase transition phenomenon. ### Background and Problem Description 1. **System Description**: - The granular system is confined in a shallow horizontal box with vertical vibrations, forming a quasi two-dimensional geometry. - The system injects energy through collisions between the particles and the top and bottom walls, which is then transferred to the horizontal degrees of freedom through inter-particle collisions. - This mechanism is dissipative because friction and inelastic effects lead to energy loss. 2. **Phase Transition Phenomenon**: - When the vibration amplitude exceeds a certain threshold, the system undergoes a non-equilibrium phase transition, separating into dense and sparse phases. - The sparse phase exhibits a crystalline structure similar to a solid. This phenomenon has been studied in detail, including its coarsening, crystallization, cage dynamics, criticality, and universality. 3. **Limitations of Existing Models**: - In three-dimensional models, particle collisions need to consider geometric constraints, making the analysis complex. - Some simplified models can simulate energy injection but fail to reach a steady state, or the steady-state temperature is independent of density, leading to the inability to produce van der Waals loops and thus failing to explain phase separation. ### Solution 1. **Effective Two-Dimensional Model**: - In the model, each particle has an additional scalar degree of freedom $\epsilon$ besides horizontal motion, representing the kinetic energy stored in the vertical direction. - $\epsilon$ increases monotonically during free flight, simulating the energy gained when particles collide with the vibrating walls. - Upon collision, the energy of $\epsilon$ is instantly transferred to the horizontal degrees of freedom, and $\epsilon$ is reset to zero. 2. **Theoretical Analysis**: - Kinetic theory predicts the conditions that the energy growth function $G(t)$ must satisfy to produce phase separation. - These predictions are verified through molecular dynamics simulations. 3. **Model Improvement**: - A saturation mechanism is introduced, allowing $\epsilon$ to reach a maximum value at low density, avoiding the issue of non-zero pressure in the sparse limit. - The correlation between velocity and flight time is considered, and it is found that these correlations have a weak impact on pressure behavior, further validating the model's effectiveness. ### Conclusion This paper successfully proposes an effective two-dimensional model that can reproduce the phase separation phenomenon in a quasi two-dimensional granular system under vertical vibrations. Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulations, the accuracy and reliability of the model are verified. This model provides new perspectives and tools for understanding phase transitions in non-equilibrium granular systems.

Effective two-dimensional model for granular matter with phase separation

Collisional Dissipation Rate in Shearing Flows of Granular Liquid Crystals.

Phase separation of a driven granular gas in annular geometry

van der Waals-like phase separation instability of a driven granular gas in three dimensions

Universality and criticality of a second-order granular solid-liquid-like phase transition

Stresses and orientational order in shearing flows of granular liquid crystals.

Topographic Control of Order in Quasi-2D Granular Phase Transitions

From the granular Leidenfrost state to buoyancy-driven convection

Coarsening in granular systems

Self-assembly and non-equilibrium phase coexistence in a binary granular mixture

Two-dimensional melting far from equilibrium in a granular monolayer

Phase transition in monodisperse granular materials: How to model it by using a strain hardening visco‐elastic‐plastic constitutive relationship

Fluctuations and criticality of a granular solid-liquid-like phase transition

Nonequilibrium Statistical Mechanics and Hydrodynamics for a Granular Fluid

The effects of forcing and dissipation on phase transitions in thin granular layers

Microscopic Model for Granular Stratification and Segregation

Phase Transition in a Out-of-equilibrium Monolayer of Dipolar Vibrated Grains

Continuum modelling and simulation of granular flows through their many phases

Constitutive model for solid-like, liquid-like, and gas-like phases of granular media and their numerical implementation

Non-equilibrium coexistence between a fluid and a hotter or colder crystal of granular hard disks

Dynamic discrete model for the granular matter formation process