L. Zieve,E. Hill
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the observational constraints faced by the accretion disk model of the Big Blue Bump (BBB) in active galactic nuclei (AGN). Specifically, the author R. Antonucci explored various limitations imposed on the accretion disk model by optical/ultraviolet (UV) observations and pointed out that these limitations are often not fully emphasized, especially when modeling X - ray emissions.
### Main problems include:
1. **Lyman Edge Feature**:
- Theoretical models predict that there will be significant absorption features at the Lyman edge, but actual observations have not found obvious partial, broadened, or systematic edge features.
- For example, the model of Kolykhalov and Sunyaev (1984) predicted huge Lyman edge absorption, but actual observations did not support this prediction (Antonucci et al., 1989; Koratkar et al., 1992).
2. **Polarization Characteristics**:
- Early models assumed that the AGN accretion disk was a pure scattering atmosphere, and the expected polarization degree was 1 - 10%, but the actually observed polarization degree was far lower than this (<∼1%) and was parallel to the radio jet direction (Stockman et al., 1979).
- This low polarization degree is difficult to explain with a simple geometrically flat Comptonized corona and may require considering Faraday depolarization or other mechanisms (Agol and Blaes, 1995).
3. **Spectral Turnover**:
- The spectra of AGN show different characteristics in low - luminosity and high - luminosity cases. Although theoretically it is expected that the higher the luminosity, the lower the temperature, actual observations show that the soft X - ray excess in Seyfert galaxies and quasars is similar (Walter and Fink, 1993).
- The spectra of quasars in the optical/near - ultraviolet band are flatter than those of Seyfert galaxies, corresponding to a higher temperature.
4. **Variability**:
- Observations show that the rapid in - phase changes of recombination lines and the optical continuum are inconsistent with the quasi - static viscous model (Alloin et al., 1985). This indicates that each ring in the accretion disk must communicate at a speed close to the speed of light.
- The amplitude of variability is usually large in the UV band and can even reach the order of unity within a few years (Cutri et al., 1985).
5. **Role of Infrared Radiation Sources**:
- Almost all accretion disk models predict that \(F_\nu\) increases with frequency, but for most quasars, \(F_\nu\) decreases with frequency after removing the small blue bump feature.
- In fact, the infrared component is considered to be thermal dust emission rather than the radiation of the accretion disk itself (Barvainis, 1992).
6. **Opaque Partial Covering**:
- Some absorption lines show opaque partial covering features, meaning that these absorption clouds cover part of the continuous radiation source but do not completely block it (Antonucci, 1993).
- This poses a challenge to the accretion disk model because macroscopic absorption clouds cannot precisely cut the continuous radiation source.
7. **Microlensing Constraints**:
- Microlensing effect studies show that the luminosity of some quasars must come from a very small scale, beyond the expectation of the accretion disk model (Rauch and Blandford, 1991).
### Summary
Through a detailed analysis of the above problems, this paper points out the main challenges faced by existing accretion disk models in explaining BBB and emphasizes the need for more complex physical mechanisms to explain the observational data. These problems not only involve the properties of the accretion disk itself but also the influence of the surrounding environment (such as dust, gas, etc.).