Corrigendum: Efficient derivation and inducible differentiation of expandable skeletal myogenic cells from human ES and patient-specific iPS cells

S. Maffioletti,M. Gerli,M. Ragazzi,Sumitava Dastidar,S. Benedetti,M. Loperfido,T. VandenDriessche,M. Chuah,Francesco Saverio Tedesco

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nprot0915-1457d

IF: 14.8

2015-07-01

Nature Protocols

Abstract:

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to study the dynamical evolution of black - hole spacetime by combining numerical relativity and perturbation theory, especially during the process of two black holes colliding. Specifically, the author explores the step - by - step method from axisymmetric to full three - dimensional simulations and emphasizes the synergy between perturbation theory and numerical simulations to enhance confidence in current results and provide tools for future binary - black - hole merger simulations.

### Main problems
1. **Challenges in numerical simulations**:
- Black - hole numerical simulations are very difficult because one must simultaneously handle the highly nonlinear region inside the singularity, near the event horizon, and the linear region in the radiation zone.
- Using the traditional singularity - avoiding time - slicing method in 3D will lead to numerical instability, making the simulation difficult to carry out.

2. **Application of perturbation theory**:
- Perturbation theory plays an important role in verifying and interpreting numerical simulation results, especially when extracting waveforms and dealing with black - hole initial data sets.
- By applying perturbation theory to numerical relativity, one can better understand the dynamics of distorted and colliding black holes.

### Solutions
- **Combination of perturbation theory and numerical simulation**:
- Use perturbation theory to test and interpret fully nonlinear numerical simulation results.
- Transition gradually from the simple axisymmetric case to the complex 3D simulation, forming a "confidence ladder".

- **Specific applications**:
- **Waveform extraction**: Extract waveforms by decomposing the numerically generated metric into a spherically symmetric part and a perturbed part and using spherical - harmonic - function projection.
- **Axisymmetric distorted black hole**: Study the evolution of a single axisymmetric black hole under the influence of gravitational waves and verify the consistency of linear and nonlinear results.
- **Axisymmetric black - hole collision**: Use perturbation theory to simulate black - hole collisions in two limit cases (approximate limit and long - distance limit).
- **3D test platform**: Extend the existing axisymmetric initial data set to 3D simulations and verify the consistency of results of different codes.

### Conclusion
By combining numerical relativity and perturbation theory, the author shows the effectiveness of this method in studying black - hole dynamics, especially for highly distorted and colliding black - hole systems. This not only enhances confidence in existing results but also provides a powerful tool for future complex simulations.

### Formula summary
- **Metric decomposition**:
\[
g_{\alpha\beta}=\bar{g}_{\alpha\beta}+h_{\alpha\beta}
\]
where \(\bar{g}_{\alpha\beta}\) is the Schwarzschild background metric and \(h_{\alpha\beta}\) is a small perturbation.

- **Zerilli equation**:
\[
\frac{\partial^{2}\psi^{(\ell m)}}{\partial r_{*}^{2}}-\frac{\partial^{2}\psi^{(\ell m)}}{\partial t^{2}}+V^{(\ell)}(r)\psi^{(\ell m)} = 0
\]
where
\[
V^{(\ell)}(r)=\left(1-\frac{2M}{r}\right)\left[\frac{1}{\Lambda^{2}}\left(\frac{72M^{3}}{r^{5}}-\frac{12M}{r^{3}}(\ell - 1)(\ell + 2)\left(1-\frac{3M}{r}\right)\right)+\frac{\ell(\ell - 1)(\ell + 2)(\ell + 1)}{r^{2}\Lambda}\right]
\]
\(r_{*}\) is the so - called tortoise coordinate, defined as \(r_{*}=r + 2M\ln(r/2M - 1)\), and \(\Lambda\) is a function depending on \(r\).

These formulas show the core content of perturbation theory and are used to describe the gravitational perturbation of Schwarzschild black holes.