L. Vaidman
Abstract:Counterfactuals in quantum theory are briefly reviewed and it is argued that they are very different from counterfactuals considered in the general philosophical literature. The issue of time symmetry of quantum counterfactuals is considered and a novel time-symmetric definition of quantum counterfactuals is proposed. This definition is applied for analyzing several controversies related to quantum counterfactuals.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the time - symmetry problem of counterfactuals in quantum theory. Specifically, the author Lev Vaidman believes that quantum counterfactuals are very different from counterfactuals in general philosophical literature, and in quantum theory, counterfactuals should have time - symmetry.
### Core problems and goals of the paper
1. **Define quantum counterfactuals**:
- The author points out that there is ambiguity and controversy in quantum counterfactuals in the existing literature. In order to make these statements useful tools, they must be strictly defined.
- The author proposes a strict time - symmetric definition to clarify issues related to quantum counterfactuals, especially the time - symmetry problem.
2. **The importance of time - symmetry**:
- The author emphasizes the importance of time - symmetry in quantum counterfactuals. He believes that time - symmetric counterfactuals can better explain quantum phenomena and avoid some philosophical confusions.
- The time - symmetric definition proposed by the author is applicable to pre - and post - selected systems, which is a feature that classical counterfactuals do not have.
3. **Applications and controversies**:
- The author applies the time - symmetric formula to counterfactual situations and solves the controversy caused by the ABL formula (Aharonov - Bergmann - Lebowitz rule).
- The author also discusses how to use the time - symmetric definition to analyze various attempts involving relativistic causality, especially the problem of proving quantum non - locality in Hardy - type experiments.
### Main contributions
- **Time - symmetric definition**: The author proposes a new time - symmetric definition, which enables quantum counterfactuals to be applied to a wider range of situations, including those where future information is known.
- **Solve controversies**: By introducing the time - symmetric definition, the author provides clear solutions to some long - standing controversies, such as Stapp's non - locality proof.
- **Expand applicability**: This definition is not only applicable to quantum physics, but also can be applied to counterfactuals in classical physics, although in classical physics, due to determinism limitations, its application range is relatively narrow.
In conclusion, this paper aims to make quantum counterfactuals more rigorous and practical by introducing a time - symmetric definition, thus providing a new perspective for understanding quantum phenomena.