Abstract:This study examines the siting scenarios for renewable energy installations (REI) in a mountainous region of Europe (Switzerland), incorporating the external costs of ecosystem services and, innovatively, social preferences. This approach challenges the prevalent techno-economic siting paradigm, which often overlooks these externalities. To minimize the external costs of the scenarios while maximizing energy yield, Marxan, an optimization software, was employed. The energy target for all scenarios is set at 25 TWh/a, stemming from the energy gap anticipated due to the phase-out of Swiss nuclear reactors by 2050. This target is met using renewable energy infrastructure such as wind, roof-mounted photovoltaic, and ground-mounted photovoltaic systems. By integrating social preferences into the optimization, this study showcases a promising implementation that transcends the software’s intended applications. It complements techno-economic approaches and offers alternative decision-making avenues. The conventional "roof first" strategy proved ineffective in preventing extensive land use for the development of new renewable energy infrastructure. Strategies incorporating ground-mounted photovoltaic infrastructure were more spatially, ecologically, and socially efficient than those without. The strategy optimized for energy yield exhibited the highest spatial efficiency but incurred significant ecosystem service costs and, surprisingly, had low social costs. In contrast, the strategy prioritizing ecosystem services was the most efficient in terms of ecosystem service costs but had elevated social costs and was spatially less efficient than other strategies. The strategy optimized for social preferences incurred the lowest social costs and excelled in spatial efficiency and ecosystem service costs. Notably, this strategy employed a limited number of planning units linked to both high ecosystem service and social costs. The findings underscore that incorporating social preferences significantly enhances the evaluation of siting options. This inclusion allows for the social acceptance of investments to be factored into costs, facilitating more informed and inclusive decisions.

Quantifying social factors for onshore wind planning – A systematic review

Integration of disamenity costs and equality considerations regarding onshore wind power expansion and distribution into energy system optimization models

Exploring the trilemma of cost-efficient, equitable and publicly acceptable onshore wind expansion planning

Reviewing methods and assumptions for high-resolution large-scale onshore wind energy potential assessments

Global Review on Environmental Impacts of Onshore Wind Energy in the Field of Tension between Human Societies and Natural Systems

International experiences with opposition to wind energy siting decisions: lessons for environmental and social appraisal

Environmental Impact Assessment Review

Onshore versus offshore wind power trends and recent study practices in modeling of wind turbines’ life-cycle impact assessments

A Review of Optimization Technologies for Large-scale Wind Farm Planning with Practical and Prospective Concerns

Assessing the Impact of Offshore Wind Siting Strategies on the Design of the European Power System

Toward a Survey-Based Assessment of Wind Turbine Noise: The Impacts on Wellbeing of Local Residents

Why energy models should integrate social and environmental factors: Assessing user needs, omission impacts, and real-word accuracy in the European Union

To support or oppose renewable energy projects? A systematic literature review on the factors influencing landscape design and social acceptance

Spatial Trade-Offs in National Land-Based Wind Power Production in Times of Biodiversity and Climate Crises

Investigating the Environmental Footprint of Solar and Wind Energy Systems

Shifting from techno-economic to socio-ecological priorities: Incorporating landscape preferences and ecosystem services into the siting of renewable energy infrastructure

Data-driven large-scale spatial planning framework for determining size and location of offshore wind energy development: A case study of China

The eco-conscious wind turbine: design beyond purely economic metrics

Complete joint-optimization for offshore wind farm planning

A new model for environmental and economic evaluation of renewable energy systems: The case of wind turbines

Applying Value Sensitive Design (VSD) to Wind Turbines and Wind Parks: An Exploration