Can one learn anything from proton-proton bremsstrahlung? Comment on H. W. Fearing preprint <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="nucl-th/9710061" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/nucl-th/9710061">nucl-th/9710061</a>

D. L. Pursey,A. M. Shirokov,T. A. Weber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.nucl-th/9712021

1997-12-06

Abstract:Recently, Fearing (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="nucl-th/9710061" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/nucl-th/9710061">nucl-th/9710061</a>) has argued that, as a matter of principle, proton-proton bremsstrahlung can yield no more information about the off-shell properties of the nucleon-nucleon interaction than can already be deduced from the on-shell properties. In this note we challenge Fearing's conclusion.

Nuclear Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to challenge and refute the views put forward by Fearing in his previous work (nucl - th/9710061). Fearing believes that, in principle, proton - proton bremsstrahlung cannot provide more information about the off - shell properties of the nucleon - nucleon interaction than what has already been deduced from the on - shell properties.

Specifically, Fearing put forward two main arguments:

1. **Unsolvable ambiguity**: He believes that the contributions in proton - proton bremsstrahlung come from the nucleon - nucleon interaction and so - called "contact terms", which cannot be calculated in principle using potential models, thus leading to an unsolvable ambiguity.
2. **The influence of field transformations**: He points out that certain off - shell contributions can be completely eliminated by field transformations because these transformations do not change the S - matrix but will affect those off - shell contributions that are not directly deduced from the on - shell properties.

### The author's refutation

The author of this paper makes the following refutations to Fearing's views:

1. **Differences in contact terms**: The author believes that although there are non - calculable contact terms, under certain conditions, such as using the distorted wave Born approximation (DWBA), this ambiguity can be minimized. They also point out that in the non - relativistic limit, the contributions of irreducible contact terms will be suppressed.
2. **Limitations of field transformations**: The author questions Fearing's claim that field transformations can completely eliminate off - shell contributions. They believe that Fearing's results rely on a simple pion model and are not applicable to more complex nucleon - nucleon systems. Moreover, if the underlying field theory of the hypothesis changes, for example, from the nucleon - meson field theory to the quark - gluon - Goldstone boson field theory, Fearing's argument will no longer hold.
3. **Differences between different models**: The author cites recent work, showing that the distorted wave calculations based on different potential models (such as the Paris potential, the Hamada - Johnston potential and the Moscow potential) show significant differences in the cross - section of proton - proton bremsstrahlung, especially in the momentum region where hard photons are emitted. This further supports their view that proton - proton bremsstrahlung can indeed provide new information about the off - shell properties of the nucleon - nucleon interaction.

### Summary

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to prove that proton - proton bremsstrahlung can provide additional information about the off - shell properties of the nucleon - nucleon interaction, rather than just repeating what is already known in the on - shell properties. The author refutes Fearing's views by analyzing the influence of contact terms, the limitations of field transformations and the differences between different models.