Abstract:We have studied the impact of incoming preparation and demographic variables on student performance on the final exam in physics 1, the standard introductory, calculus-based mechanics course This was done at three different institutions using multivariable regression analysis to determine the extent to which exam scores can be predicted by a variety of variables that are available to most faculty and departments. We have found that the results are surprisingly consistent across the institutions, with the only two variables that have predictive power being math SAT/ACT scores and concept inventory pre-scores. The importance of both variables is comparable and fairly similar across the institutions. They explain 20 - 30 percent of the variation in students' performance on the final exam. Most notably, the demographic variables (gender, under-represented minority, first generation to attend college) are not significant. In all cases, although there appear to be gaps in exam performance if one considers only the demographic variable, once these two proxies of incoming preparation are included in the model, there is no longer a demographic gap. There is only a preparation gap that applies equally across the entire student population. This work shows that to properly understand differences in student performance across a diverse population, and hence to design more effective instruction, it is important to do statistical analyses that take multiple variables into account. It also illustrates the importance of having measures that are sensitive to both subject specific and more general preparation. The results suggest that better matching of the course design and teaching to the incoming student preparation will likely be the most effective way to eliminate observed performance gaps across demographic groups while also improving the success of all students.

A class where qualitative discussions, coming weeks before computationally complicated practice, helps students' problem solving abilities

Improving student's problem-solving ability as well as conceptual understanding without sacrificing the physics content of a class

Learning Concepts First: A Course Structure with Improved Educational Outcomes in the Short, Medium, and Long Terms (Especially for Minority Groups Underrepresented in Physics)

An equitable and effective approach to introductory mechanics

Student performance analysis of virtual introductory calculus-based physics class

Coupling Conceptual and Quantitative Problems to Develop Expertise in Introductory Physics Students

Implementing Elements of The Physics Suite at a Large Metropolitan Research University

Junior high school physics: Using a qualitative strategy for successful problem solving

Developing Peer Instruction questions for quantitative problems for an upper-division astronomy course

Epistemic Impact on Group Problem Solving for Different Science Majors

From F=ma to Flying Squirrels: Curricular Change in an Introductory Physics Course

A Case Study: Novel Group Interactions through Introductory Computational Physics

Conceptual problem solving in high school physics

Comparing the Matter and Interactions Curriculum with a Traditional Physics Curriculum: A Think Aloud Study

${\rm P}^3$: A Practice Focused Learning Environment

Effective Model and Strategies for Online Teaching and Learning of Introductory Physics in the Era of ChatGPT

Using Isomorphic Problems to Learn Introductory Physics

Improvement or selection? A longitudinal analysis of students' views about experimental physics in their lab courses

Sixteen years of Collaborative Learning through Active Sense-making in Physics (CLASP) at UC Davis

Students taught by a first-time instructor using active learning teaching strategies outperform students taught by a highly-regarded traditional instructor

The impact of incoming preparation and demographics on performance in Physics I: a multi-institution comparison