Abstract:Purpose: Virus epidemics may be mitigated if people comply with directives to stay at home and keep their distance from strangers in public. As such, there is a public health interest in social distancing compliance. The available evidence on distancing practices in public space is limited, however, by the lack of observational data. Here, we apply video observation as a method to examine to what extent members of the public comply with social distancing directives. Data: Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) footage of interactions in public was collected in inner-city Amsterdam, the Netherlands. From the footage, we observed instances of people violating the 1.5-meter distance directives in the weeks before, during, and after these directives were introduced to mitigate the COVID-19 pandemic. Results: We find that people complied with the 1.5-meter distance directives when these directives were first introduced, but that the level of compliance started to decline soon after. We also find that violation of the 1.5-meter distance directives is strongly associated with the number of people observed on the street and with non-compliance to stay-at-home directives, operationalized with large-scale aggregated location data from cell phones. All three measures correlate to a varying extent with temporal patterns in the transmission of the COVID-19 virus, temperature, COVID-19 related Google search queries, and media attention to the topic. Conclusion: Compliance with 1.5 meter distance directives is short-lived and coincides with the number of people on the street and with compliance to stay-at-home directives. Potential implications of these findings are that keep- distance directives may work best in combination with stay-at-home directives and place-specific crowd-control strategies, and that the number of people on the street and community-wide mobility as captured with cell phone data offer easily measurable proxies for the extent to which people keep sufficient physical distance from others at specific times and locations.

The effects of social distancing markers on single-file pedestrian movement during the pandemic

Dynamic Analysis of Single-File Pedestrian Movement with Maintaining Social Distancing in Times of Pandemic

Pedestrians’ behavior in emergency evacuation: Modeling and simulation*

Improved social force model considering the influence of COVID-19 pandemic: pedestrian evacuation under regulation

Stay Two-Meters Apart: Assessing the Impact of COVID-19 Social Distancing Protocols on Subway Station Walkway Performance

A Dynamic Sensitivity Model for Unidirectional Pedestrian Flow With Overtaking Behaviour and Its Application on Social Distancing's Impact During COVID-19

Social distancing in pedestrian dynamics and its effect on disease spreading

Social distancing and the future of pedestrian dynamics

A Dynamic Physical-Distancing Model to Evaluate Spatial Measures for Prevention of Covid-19 Spread

The Impact of COVID-19 on Pedestrian Flow Patterns in Urban POIs—An Example from Beijing

Modeling indoor-level non-pharmaceutical interventions during the COVID-19 pandemic: A pedestrian dynamics-based microscopic simulation approach

Experimental Study and Analysis on Behaviours and Strategies of Social Groups and Individuals

A novel social distancing analysis in urban public space: A new online spatio-temporal trajectory approach

The effect of moving obstacle on regulation of pedestrian flow in a single exit room

Improved Social Force Model based on Pedestrian Collision Avoidance Behavior in Counterflow

Social Distancing with the Optimal Steps Model

Social distancing compliance: A video observational analysis

Analysis of movement behavior of pedestrian social groups through a bottleneck

Predicting physical distancing on recreational trails during COVID-19

Social Groups Barely Change the Speed-Density Relationship in Unidirectional Pedestrian Flow, but Affect Operational Behaviours

Agent-based simulation of pedestrian dynamics for exposure time estimation in epidemic risk assessment