Abstract:Data-driven decision making in agriculture can be augmented by utilizing the data gathered from precision agriculture technologies to make the most informed decisions that consider spatiotemporal specificity. Decision support systems utilize underlying models of crop responses to generate management recommendations, yet there is uncertainty in the literature on the best model forms to characterize crop responses to agricultural inputs likely due for the most part to the variability in crop responses to input rates between fields and across years. Seven fields with at least three years of on-farm experimentation, in which nitrogen fertilizer rates were varied across the fields, were used to compare the ability of five different model types to forecast crop responses and net-returns in a year unseen by the model. All five model types were fit for each field using all permutations of the three years of data where two years were used for training and a third was held out to represent a "future" year. The five models tested were a frequentist based non-linear sigmoid function, a generalized additive model, a non-linear Bayesian regression model, a Bayesian multiple linear regression model and a random forest regression model. The random forest regression typically resulted in the most accurate forecasts of crop responses and net-returns across most fields. However, in some cases the model type that produced the most accurate forecast of grain yield was not the same as the model producing the most accurate forecast of grain protein concentration. Models performed best when the data used for training models was collected from years with similar weather conditions to the forecasted year. The results are important to developers of decision support tools because the underlying models used to simulate management outcomes and calculate net-returns need to be selected with consideration for the spatiotemporal specificity of the data available.

An Empirical Test of Utility vs. Profit Maximization in Agricultural Production

The Influence of Uncertainty on the Choice of Business Relationships: the Case of Vegetable Farmers in China

Empirical Research on the Relationship Between Farmers' Land Management Scale and Food Production Efficiency

A Revenue-Function Approach to the Measurement of Output-Substitution Possibilities in Agriculture

A Shadow‐Price Frontier Measurement of Profit Efficiency in Chinese Agriculture

Market Efficiency and Marketing to Enhance Income of Crop Producers

A Bayesian Analysis of Vegetable Production in Japan

A Framework for Economic Analysis of Cropping Systems: Profitability, Risk Management, and Resource Allocation

Limits to Profit Maximization as a Guide to Behavior Change

Multi-Output Broadacre Agricultural Production: Estimating A Cost Function Using Quasi-Micro Farm Level Data from Australia

Technical and environmental inefficiency measurement in agriculture using a flexible by‐production stochastic frontier model

Farm decision making under risk and uncertainty

An alternative method of measuring economic efficiency: The case of grain production in China

Effect of yield and price risk on conversion from conventional to organic farming

Efficiency or Equity? the Effect of an Exogenous Agricultural Commercial Shock: Evidence from Manchuria in the 1930S

Multicrop Production Decisions in Western Irrigated Agriculture: The Role of Water Price

Socially Beneficial Rationality: The Value of Strategic Farmers, Social Entrepreneurs, and For-Profit Firms in Crop Planting Decisions

Assessing performance of empirical models for forecasting crop responses to variable fertilizer rates using on-farm precision experimentation

Input Substitution, Productivity Performance and Farm Size